Giuliani: Kids of illegal immigrants should keep US citizenship

breakingnews.nypost.com ^ | November 30, 2007 | By JIM DAVENPORT

[Jane Austen]

While Rudy is for abortion, yet he wants the children of illegal aliens to be citizens. Rudy is all wrong on this. Constitution says nothing about illegal aliens’ children. This is one step to sneak in amnesty and that is why Rudy, the Huckster, and McCain are for it.

[Sir Francis Dashwood]

That lyin’ sack...

[wardaddy]

The Constitution doesn’t exactly say that, but it is how the courts have interpreted it, which in realistic terms means the same thing.

actually ...that notion is a cornerstone of what many of us here oppose....

[Sonora]

You’ve now convinced me - Ruby seems like a real likable guy that can really take it to Clinton, but there appears to be way too much liberal thinking baggage and he seems to be a stubborn sort that will not stick to promised ways of thinking that include a conservative agenda - in other words - I no longer trust him, just look what he did within his marriage - practically an in your face scenario.

Besides, he really does seem closed minded on a lot of issues, just being political to secure conservative votes on so many issues - let’s all dump him back to New York.

[Squantos]

Voting independent for sure if this POS is the GOP anointed one !

[Beagle8U]

“Both are way, way to the left of Hunter, Thompson,”

You should have stopped there because Romney is nothing close to conservative.

[Tijeras_Slim]

Did the rain make it out your way? We got an inch last night, I swear all between 4 and 5 AM from the sound. The dogs were hiding under the covers.

[org.whodat]

The Constitution doesn’t exactly say that, but it is how the courts have interpreted it, which in realistic terms means the same thing.

No it means that if it was appealed another court could see the matter differently.

[Jane Austen]

I did not say that.

But Romney is way to the right of the Huckster, Rudy, and McCain.

[org.whodat]

Here is a site that puts the Illegals in terms that even a moron like Rooty should understand.

Dane are one of her/his buds will be along shortly to call you names. LOL

[trisham]

Giuliani for dogcatcher bump.

[CyberAnt]

Where is that in the Constitution ..??

[Jim Robinson]

The offspring of illegal aliens should not be US citizens. Period.

[Varda]

Than change the Constitution... good luck with that.

[Beagle8U]

“But Romney is way to the right of the Huckster, Rudy, and McCain”

Nope. I put Romney in the same bucket as Rooty.

[org.whodat]

This means that tourists and legal immigrants can pop out Baby Americans but illegal immigrants, even if here for decades, may not. It would definitely be a deterrent to illegals as well.

I do believe the clause, subject to the jurisdiction means that.

"All persons born or naturalized in the United States, and subject to the jurisdiction thereof, are citizens of the United States and of the State wherein they reside."

[Beagle8U]

Let him/her/it.

I don’t take much crap from anyone.

[Squantos]

Yep blew thru here about 10Am w/ 45mph winds........was really warm 68 degrees and then the front passed and it dropped to 40’s and now is back up almost 70 !

Ahhhhh weather ! Came a real turd floater it did !

[Jim Robinson]

No need to change the constitution. Erroneous court decisions are sometimes overturned and corrected by later courts. Thank God for that.

[org.whodat]

We don’t worry about separating kids from american parents when those parents are sent to jail for crimes so why would we care here.

Don't give the huckster anymore feel good ideals, he will want to start having murders live at home, just the Christian thing to do you know.