[Antoninus]

All the “crying wolf” over the harmless Harry Potter novels unfortunately undermines attempts to oppose real evil like the Pullman series.

There was no "crying wolf" about Harry Potter, as it turns out...

A Catholic Homeschool Father Won't Bother to Review the Rest of the Harry Potters

[Sloth]

I’ve already read that, and found it irrelevant.

[Charles Martel]

There was no "crying wolf" about Harry Potter, as it turns out...

Pullman's comments about his atheist agenda and its presence in his written works are actually supported by the books in question. Rowling's "outing" of a character is not.

Pullman can only benefit from these comparisons.