Posted on 10/07/2007 1:53:58 PM PDT by calcowgirl
LOL!!
The apportionment of the House is based on the resident population of the country and not the citizen population.
I assume this is a constitutional req. and am now looking further into this issue.
Also, we should remember that women and blacks were not allowed to vote back in the day.
Illegals get better representation than do the taxpaying citizens of this country.
Do illegal aliens count in the Census? If they do, there might be a need to reassess the purpose of the Census.
Ping!
Here is a paper on this subject.
I just found it and haven’t read it all.
http://www.mnforsustain.org/cis_immigration_congressional_reapportionment_poston_d.htm
Question is are we past the tipping point? I’m afraid the America as we know it may not be the same in the future. We may be making a sharp turn to the left. If Hillary gets elected I’m afraid it is all over but the shouting. Just look at states like New Mexico and Nevada. They never come back to be Republican.
an exerpt:
At present it is not clear whether the Constitution requires non-citizens to be counted for apportionment, but it is clear that any attempt to exclude them would result in years of litigation.7
You would think non-citizens couldn’t vote, so why count ‘em? Or better yet, why can’t Census takers report them when they find them? Oh, yeah, that would scare them off—wouldn’t want that to happen. And where exactly will the loyalies of these new Congresspeople lie? I’ll give you uno guess.
No one has done more to cheapen American citizenship than our “leaders”. I despise them.
Then isn't that admitting we know where they are to either ARREST them, DEPORT them or god forbid BOTH!
Sadly, I think we passed the tipping point long ago. GW could have turned the tide had he tried border enforcement after 9/11, but no dice. If Hillary succeeds him, it is all over. We will throw our doors open to the Third World even wider. And if you don’t like it, you will get thrown in jail for inciting racial hatred.
My fear: One hundred years from now, Americans of European descent will be virtual economic slaves—taxed to near extinction by our liberal overlords, their will enforce by hordes of third world freeloaders.
It isn’t the vote I am concerned with, as I believe that all CITIZENS should be allowed to vote. But the apportionment of seats by all residents, and not just citizens is WRONG. I believe that such an application would be a misinterpretation of the Constitution.
If they are undocumented, how does anybody prove that they are actually there? And, just who is in charge of providing the official count of people who aren’t there?
I agree. I worked on the last census in New Orleans, Louisiana. The workers go to apartments for up to three times. Usually no one answers. You can only go to the apartment so many times and then move on. You can only guess who lives there. The ones who answer the doors say 3 live there when 8 actually live there. In an apartment situation, it it impossible to count who lives there and the neighbors will not help you. Seeing that there are thousands of apartments in NO and Metairie you can see that the census can really be scewed. I did input of data from the census so I know the problems the people had in the field. I don’t think it is possible to even guess how many illegals are in this country.
They see the way to a permanent majority, and nothing will stop them at this point.
Yes.
an exerpt:
At present it is not clear whether the Constitution requires non-citizens to be counted for apportionment, but it is clear that any attempt to exclude them would result in years of litigation.**************
We’re are in full agreement. I was merely adding info on a possible reason for the counting of “residents” vs citizens. It is not unconstitutional but can be changed by congress.
Bumper sticker for all of 2008:
KEEP
TAXES HIGH
BORDERS OPEN
MARRIAGE GAY
VOTE DEMOCRAT
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.