Posted on 09/28/2007 6:48:45 AM PDT by SJackson
| Ahmadinejad's Holocaust Myths |
In his speeches, most especially the one at Columbia University, Mahmoud Ahmadinejad repeats two myths about the Holocaust. The first every reasonable person knows is a total lie: namely that the Holocaust did not occur. The second myth, however, is one that escapes critical attention for the most part, because many people are not aware of its falsity. The myth is that the Palestinian people and their leadership had absolutely nothing to do with the Holocaust. The conclusion that is supposed to follow from this fact is that the establishment of Israel in the wake of the Nazi genocide of the Jewish people was unfair to the Palestinians. This is the way Ahmadinejad put it in his Columbia talk.
[G]iven this historical event [the Holocaust], if it is a reality, we need to question whether the Palestinian people should be paying for it
The Palestinian people didnt commit any crime. They had no role to play in World War II.
These statements about the role of the Palestinians are demonstrably false. The truth is that the Palestinian leadership, supported by the Palestinian masses, played a significant role in Hitlers Holocaust. The Palestinian leader at the time was Hajj Amin Al-Husseini, the Grand Mufit of Jerusalem. As Professor Edward Said has acknowledged:
Hajj Amin al-Husseini represented the Palestinian Arab national consensus, had the backing of the Palestinian political parties that functioned in Palestine, and was recognized in some form by Arab governments as the voice of the Palestinian people.
Husseini was Palestines national leader and it was in that capacity that he made his notorious alliance with Hitler and played an active role in promoting the Holocaust. Here is the true story that Ahmadinejad tried to mythologize.
Shortly after Hitler came to power, the Grand Mufti decided to emulate him. He informed the German consul in Jerusalem that the Muslims inside and outside Palestine welcome the new regime of Germany and hope for the extension of the fascist anti-democratic, governmental system to other countries. In an effort to bring it to his own country, Husseini organized the Nazi Scouts, based on the Hitler Youth. The swastika became a welcome symbol among many Palestinians.
The mid to late 1930s were marked by Arab efforts to curtail immigration and Jewish efforts to rescue as many Jews as possible from Hitlers Europe. These years were also marked by escalating Muslim violence orchestrated by Husseini and other Muslim leaders. In 1936, Arab terrorism took on a new dimension. In the beginning the targets were once again defenseless Jewish civilians in hospitals, movie theatres, homes and stores. This was followed by strikes and shop closures, and then by the bombing of British offices. The Nazi regime in Germany and the Italian fascists supported the violence, sending millions to the Mufti. The SS, under the leadership of Heinrich Himmler, provided both financial and logistical support for anti-Semitic pogroms in Palestine. Adolf Eichmann visited Husseini in Palestine and subsequently maintained regular contact with him. The support was mutual, as one Arab commentator put it:
Feeling the whip of Jewish pressure and influence, the Arabs sympathized with the Nazis and Fascists in their agony and trials at the hands of Jewish intrigues and international financial pressures.
The Palestinians and their Arab allies were anything but neutral about the fate of European Jewry. The official leader of the Palestinians, Haj Amin al-Husseini, spent the war years in Berlin with Hitler, serving as a consultant on the Jewish question. He was taken on a tour of Auschwitz by Himmler and expressed support for the mass murder of European Jews. He also sought to solve the problems of the Jewish element in Palestine and other Arab countries by employing the same method being used in the Axis countries. He would not be satisfied with the Jewish residents of Palestine - - many of whom were descendants of Sephardic Jews who had lived there for hundreds, even thousands, of years - - remaining as a minority in a Muslim state. Like Hitler, he wanted to be rid of every last Jew. As Husseini wrote in his memoirs:
Our fundamental condition for cooperating with Germany was a free hand to eradicate every last Jew from Palestine and the Arab world. I asked Hitler for an explicit undertaking to allow us to solve the Jewish problem in a manner befitting our national and racial aspirations and according to the scientific methods innovated by Germany in the handling of its Jews. The answer I got was: The Jews are yours.
The Mufti was apparently planning to return to Palestine in the event of a German victory and to construct a death camp, modeled after Auschwitz, near Nablus. Husseini incited his pro-Nazi followers with the words Arise, o sons of Arabia. Fight for your sacred rights. Slaughter Jews wherever you find them. Their spilled blood pleases Allah, our history and religion. That will save our honor. In 1944, a German-Arab commando unit, under Husseinis command, parachuted into Palestine and poisoned Tel Avivs wells.
Husseini also helped to inspire a pro-Nazi coup in Iraq and helped to organize thousands of Muslims in the Balkans into military units known as Handselar divisions which carried out atrocities against Yugoslav Jews, Serbs and Gypsies. After a meeting with Hitler, he recorded the following in his diary:
The Mufti: The Arabs were Germanys natural friends
They were therefore prepared to cooperate with Germany with all their hearts and stood ready to participate in a war, not only negatively by the commission of acts of sabotage and the instigation of revolutions, but also positively by the formation of an Arab Legion. In this struggle, the Arabs were striving for the independence and the unity of Palestine, Syria and Iraq
. Hitler: Germany was resolved, step by step, to ask one European nation after the other to solve its Jewish problem, and at the proper time direct a similar appeal to non-European nations as well. Hitler. Germanys objective would then be solely the destruction of the Jewish element residing in the Arab sphere under the protection of British power. The moment that Germanys tank divisions and air squadrons had made their appearance south of the Caucasus, the public appeal requested by the Grand Mufti could go out to the Arab world. It is fair to conclude that the official leader of the Muslims in Palestine, Haj Amin al-Husseini, was a full fledged Nazi war criminal and he was so declared at Nuremberg and sought by Yugoslavia as a war criminal after the war. He escaped to Egypt where he was given asylum and helped to organize many former Nazis and Nazi sympathizers against Israel.
It is also fair to say that Husseinis pro-Nazi sympathies and support were widespread among his Palestinian followers, who regarded him as a hero even after the war and the disclosure of his role in Nazi atrocities. According to his biographer,
Haj Amins popularity among the Palestinian Arabs and within the Arab states actually increased more than ever during his period with the Nazis
[because] large parts of the Arab world shared this sympathy with Nazi Germany during the Second World War.
Nor was it merely a hatred of Zionism that animated this support for Nazi ideology. The grand muftis hatred of Jews
was fathomless, and he gave full vent to it during his period of activity alongside the Nazis (October 1941-May 1945). His speeches on Berlin Radio were anti-Semitic to the core: Kill the Jews wherever you find themthis pleases God, history and religion. In 1948, the National Palestinian Council elected Husseini as its president, even though he was still a wanted war criminal living in exile in Egypt. Indeed, Husseini is still revered today among many Palestinians as a national hero. Yasser Arafat, in an interview conducted in 2002 and reprinted in the Palestinian daily Al-Quds on August 2, 2002, calls Haj Amin al-Husseini our hero, referring to the Palestinian people. Arafat also boasted of being one of his troops, even though he knew he was considered an ally of Nazis. (If a German today were to call Hitler our hero, he would appropriately be labeled a neo-Nazi.!)
It is a myth therefore another myth perpetrated by Irans myth-maker-in-chief that the Palestinians played no role in the Holocaust. Considering the active support by the Palestinian leadership and masses for the losing side of a genocidal war, it was more than fair for the United Nations to offer them a state of their own on more than half of the arable land of the British mandate. The Sudeten Germans got a lot less!
ping for later
Although Alan Dershowitz apparently finally saw the light after 9/11, I still hate it when I agree with him.
Yepper, same here......But it’s always nice to see someone remind the “mindless’ of the historical truth...I was talking to my wife yesterday just how far off that thing about Palis having nothing to do with ‘anything’ re WW2 and the Germans was antyhing but the truth..... Muftis and all that....
Ping for later.
High Volume. Articles on Israel can also be found by clicking on the Topic or Keyword Israel. or WOT [War on Terror]
----------------------------
Heinrich Himmler is a saint to the Palestinians.
another ping for later
And Himmler was a big fan of Islam!
Many Muslims fought alongside Nazis, not just in Muslim areas, but also in Italy and France!
Ping for later reference.
While I fully recognize the support and common cause that “Palestinian Arab leaders” made with the Nazis of the WWII era, I do not believe Hitler needed that support to either originate or desire to execute his “final solution” on the Jews in Europe.
Again, that is not a defense of the Nazi-emulating activities of “Palestinian Arab leaders” at the time. It is only an intellectually honest assessment that they did not, in my view, play a dominant role, from Hitlers point of view - he was going to do what he did, with or without “Palestinian Arab leaders” “support”.
No way of knowing. I wouldn’t say his was the dominant role, that likely belonged to Himmler, he was certainly an influential advocate.
BTW, it seems to me the article concentrates on the palestinians role as allies of the Reich rather than suggesting they were the sole genesis of the idea.
“BTW, it seems to me the article concentrates on the palestinians role as allies of the Reich rather than suggesting they were the sole genesis of the idea.”
Factually, I believe the article supports my point that the Nazis provided the “sole genesis” for the final solution, regardless of what later support they obtained from Palestinian Arabs, as “allies”.
Now, maybe my problem, in the communication of concepts, comes from the subtitle that you gave the article when you posted it - “Is it true the Palestinians had nothing to do with the Holocaust?”, more than the text of the article.
If one wants to extend the idea of the genocide of the Jews in Europe (what one commonly thinks of as “the Holocaust”) to anti-Jewish activities in Palestine as part of “the Holocaust”, one can, but I do not believe most people do or will. That’s not a judgment, just a statement of what I think most people believe.
Maybe it could be correct in an absolute sense, but if that is true then neither Britain, France or the U.S. is exempt from “sin” in that regard.
And one could say, “Is it true that Britain/France/U.S. had nothing to do with Holocaust”? I am NOT trying to imply that Britain, France or the U.S. were, as societies, committed to disenfranchising the social, political and cultural life of Jews from their presence, to such an extent as to resort to terrorism and murder to remove them? No.
But, in fact it was not until after the war that the stain of antisemitism began to finally wain (not eliminated) from western culture. Surely it too (western antisemitism) provided the means (look the other way) for some portion of the Holocaust, even as we claimed to not be “allies” of Hitler.
Yes, I agree, it does not exonerate the activities of the Palestinian Arab leaders, and yes, unlike Britain/France/U.S. THEY WERE attempting (like Hitler) to remove Jews from “their Area”.
But that attempt, by the Palestinian Arab leaders, had its own genesis, its own context, outside of the rise and reign of Hitler, and it most likely would have had its own, and likely equally brutal history, without Hitler.
Therefore, I think most people, most scholars, from a historical perspective, will recognize the Palestinian Arab leaders as allies of Hitler and supporters of Hitler, but leave “the Holocaust” label on Hitler.
Yet, in support of what you may mean in some broader concept of the Holocaust, outside of its existing historical context, it is not inconceivable, that if the Jews in Palestine had failed to be the resourceful people they have proven to be, with or without a Hitler, there could have been a different event given the “Holocaust” label in history - the removal by massacre or eviction of all the Jews from Palestine. I do not see how one can look at the motives of “the Arab nation” in 1948 and not see that possibility.
In sum, in the Historical sense of what happened, I think your subtitle is misleading; even if the concept is not completely false in the broader sense.
http://www.frontpagemag.com/
No. the Front Page magazine title is:
Ahmadinejad’s Holocaust Myths at:
http://www.frontpagemag.com/Articles/Read.aspx?GUID=E36120C9-D999-4CE1-B285-A838B7D316A2
and it does not contain the subtitle:
Is it true the Palestinians had nothing to do with the Holocaust?,
which I only find in the title you gave your post.
| Horowitz on C-Span for Three Hours, Sunday October 7. EST 12-3PM, PST 9-12AM, 9-12PM | |
![]() |
|
|
|
| Iran, Osama and 9/11 By: Jamie Glazov The media focuses on Ahmadinejads visit to Columbia -- but ignores Tehrans links to Al Qaeda and to the attacks of September 11. More> Ahmadinejad's Holocaust Myths By: Alan M. Dershowitz Is it true that the Palestinians had nothing to do with the Holocaust? More> The Kucinich Surrender Tour By: Andrew Walden From Syria to Hawaii. More> The History Channel Shills For Che Guevara By: Humberto Fontova Venerating a chief executioner. More> Fanatic Muslim Family Day By: Joe Kaufman Six Flags Over Texas opens its doors to a group with ties to terror. More> Disinvest, New York By: Dick Morris and Eileen McGann The right way to welcome Ahmadinejad to the Big Apple. More> |
|
![]() Islamist Punishment
![]() ![]() ![]() ![]()
|
The myth is that the Palestinian people and their leadership had absolutely nothing to do with the Holocaust... These statements about the role of the Palestinians are demonstrably false. The truth is that the Palestinian leadership, supported by the Palestinian masses, played a significant role in Hitler's Holocaust. The Palestinian leader at the time was Hajj Amin Al-Husseini, the Grand Mufit of Jerusalem... Husseini was "Palestine's national leader" and it was in that capacity that he made his notorious alliance with Hitler and played an active role in promoting the Holocaust... Shortly after Hitler came to power, the Grand Mufti decided to emulate him. He informed the German consul in Jerusalem that "the Muslims inside and outside Palestine welcome the new regime of Germany and hope for the extension of the fascist anti-democratic, governmental system to other countries." In an effort to bring it to his own country, Husseini organized the "Nazi Scouts," based on the "Hitler Youth." The swastika became a welcome symbol among many Palestinians. The mid to late 1930's were marked by Arab efforts to curtail immigration and Jewish efforts to rescue as many Jews as possible from Hitler's Europe. These years were also marked by escalating Muslim violence orchestrated by Husseini and other Muslim leaders. In 1936, Arab terrorism took on a new dimension. In the beginning the targets were once again defenseless Jewish civilians in hospitals, movie theatres, homes and stores. This was followed by strikes and shop closures, and then by the bombing of British offices. The Nazi regime in Germany and the Italian fascists supported the violence, sending "millions" to the Mufti. The SS, under the leadership of Heinrich Himmler, provided both financial and logistical support for anti-Semitic pogroms in Palestine. Adolf Eichmann visited Husseini in Palestine and subsequently maintained regular contact with him. The support was mutual...
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.