There is some good that comes out of these kinds of threads. Whenever I read one of the “Harry Potter is evil” posts I have more incentive to write my own fantasy story in hopes that some day I can see the naysayers on a thread about my book.
DO IT!
There is aways a shortage of good literature!
I love fantasy. And myth. And I don’t lack imagination. But witchcraft is itself inherently evil, so when it is supposedly the force of good, I have a problem with it. It confuses good and evil. I love stories with elements of the supernatural in it; the supernatural makes great fantasy. But it needs to be clear about the forces of good and evil. Witchcraft itself is not good.