Posted on 05/09/2007 6:51:49 AM PDT by Lusis
Several reasons... Pimps who prey upon young women, slavery, dirty old creeps who can't think with the appendage at the upper end of the spinal column and spread diseases.
There are more, but I don't think you are ready to have that discussion with me.
One would get the impression from your post that sex were designed for marriage and family.
How dare you declare such a thing, in the midst of our self-loving, self-loathing hedonist culture! Don’t you know we are free to destroy our civilization — “just because we can?”
/sarcasm
I'm a libertarian leaning conservative. It is true that the LP as a party does indeed "punt" on the abortion issue. They don't take a stand one way or the other. Not surprising really. They don't take a stand on anything and the platform as a party looks damn near close to anarchy. They agree on nothing other than "Gubmint should leave citizens and human beings the heck alone".
This is where it is clear to me that the true and pure libertarian argument on the abortion question IMHO is clearly on the side of pro-life. Government exists to protect people's lives and their property and to provide basic services. Not to legislate morality, redistribute wealth or conduct social engineering.
If sticking a sharp object into a human beings skull doesn't qualify as "protecting people's lives" then I don't know what the Hell does.
Kidster, you deserve Nobel Prize for your posts on this thread. I was reading it on my Blackberry in the airport.
Great stuff.
Our legal system has never been based on whether or not something is a "victimless crime". This is a libertarian myth.
The letter was not to Greeves. I don't have my copy of the Letters handy, but I see from one of my previous uses of this quote that the name of the person to whom the letter was addressed was "Mrs. Edward A. Allen".
Thanks!
That's why I want them off the streets practicing their 'craft' in a safe place.
And I don't believe it's God's plan for any person to be engaged in that biz, either as consumer or provider, no woman should be on the street.
Looks like you’re not as attracted to the Loving Grace of The LORD as you are to HIS Justice and punishment of wickedness. Hopefully, that will change, but the humbling crucible isn’t going to be fun for you.
See you on the other side!
Aren’t “emanations” akin to “auras”, and as such rightly considered to be of validity only to hte drugged counter culture types?
Hmmmn - given the many rulings which are verrrry counter to America, perhaps the Ass-inine at SCOTUS need to be tested for drugs.
how many prostitutes do you think do this “craft” because they love their “work”?
No...it is desperation, enslavement to drugs, enslavement to a pimp.
In more and more cases it is foreign women enslaved with the threat of exposure and deportment.
It is the enslavement of young runaways.
Slavery is wrong and it should be illegal.
Prostitution is bad for society - it is bad for everyone involved.
Without it, there will still be adultery and people cheating on their spouses, but when you add the element of monetary gain for the sale of a human body....that introduces the element of slavery.
Menniger Foundation did a study a number of years ago where the working girls expressed the same level as satisfaction with their work as others in the same skill levels (waitresses, cleaning staff and the like)
No...it is desperation, enslavement to drugs, enslavement to a pimp.
Not really desperation, most of these ladies are attractive enough to attract a single male and make an 'exclusive contract for services' but it's more fun to be making whopee. A lady employed in a "house" does not need or use the services of a pimp
In more and more cases it is foreign women enslaved with the threat of exposure and deportment.
I don't really want to cover Dubya's failure to carry out his constitutional duties and obligations to secure the borders. Perhaps on another thread ;^)
It is the enslavement of young runaways.
Don't believe every thing you see in Hollywood. Do you really believe heterosexual (normal) American males, while in the throes of physical passion would really ignore a lady's plea for help? Again, don't believe Hollywood.
Slavery is wrong and it should be illegal.
No argument there. Puppies should have chew toys available at all times.
Prostitution is bad for society - it is bad for everyone involved.
Probably, just don't see the need for the state to become involved in voluntary adult type activities, except to make an effort to see a disease is not passed and the chances of the participants being killed and injured are reduced. And it would probably reduce the numbers of abortion when immature males confine their premarital hank panky to the 'pros'.
Without it, there will still be adultery and people cheating on their spouses, but when you add the element of monetary gain for the sale of a human body....that introduces the element of slavery.
Trust me, those ladies are not slaves, except to making dumb decisions. And I'm hardly a Kumbaya singing liberal, I believe drug dealers and pimps should be publicly flogged and executed on their third conviction.
and you have a link to this study?
Very skeptical.
“Not really desperation, most of these ladies are attractive enough to attract a single male and make an ‘exclusive contract for services’ but it’s more fun to be making whopee. A lady employed in a “house” does not need or use the services of a pimp”
So let me get this right....you think the prostitutes are enjoying themselves? Is that right?
“Do you really believe heterosexual (normal) American males, while in the throes of physical passion would really ignore a lady’s plea for help? “
What are you talking about?
You are assuming most of these guys are “normal”?
Most “normal” men I know say things like “I would never stoop to having to pay for ‘it’”
So...the type of guys who would go to a hooker? Yeah, I can believe they don’t care much about the prostitute’s situation.
“Probably, just don’t see the need for the state to become involved in voluntary adult type activities, except to make an effort to see a disease is not passed and the chances of the participants being killed and injured are reduced. And it would probably reduce the numbers of abortion when immature males confine their premarital hank panky to the ‘pros’.”
OK...you live in a dream world where you think legalization will actually help people.
Here’s a good link refuting that idea....
http://www.rapereliefshelter.bc.ca/issues/prostitution_legalizing.html
I've never read a word of Rand, so that jab isn't going to take, friend. And the latter jab was just sloppy.You can't answer the question, so you're swinging around madly, trying to see if you can hit anything.
No, genius.
It's kooky to claim that the Catholic church "isn't really" a Christian church---that's kooky enough as is---but then, in the next breath, to claim that you "aren't an authority on what constitutes Christian morality"---that adds an element of dumbness to the kookery that makes you a true standout.
We are not like post WW2 Europe where chocolate bars and nylons are a valuable currency, they have other channels to support themselves.
Do a little research on the legal Nevada brothels, those ladies are not at risk to being murdered and anyone who would think of trying to harm one of the 'staff' there wouldn't leave the facility alive.
And us men never lie, "I'd never have to pay for it".
Ya sure.
Again, I don't believe the Man Upstairs wants anyone to do that kind of 'profession', just as he doesn't want us to steal or lie.
But by forcing them to operate outside the law, we put them at risk.
I believe Nevada has the best approach to the whole nasty business.
oh sure, Nevada has taken all the nastiness out of prostitution and made it nice and safe and all that, as we can read about here....
http://www.lvrj.com/opinion/7483782.html
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.