[MHGinTN]

When someone makes an assertion like the following, they haven't much of a clue regarding the way the Israelis are able to use DNA to trace descendants of the twelve tribes all over the world: I would not expect them to be able to find anything because DNA tracking does not work that way. The poster has thus implied that the Israelis are not finding what they are surely finding because the Israeli's methods are not making a connection to Native Americans for the LDS researchers who cannot find evidence to support Joe Smith's big lie. I think we have another dancing hamster ...

[DelphiUser]

When someone makes an assertion like the following, they haven't much of a clue regarding the way the Israelis are able to use DNA to trace descendants of the twelve tribes all over the world:

The Jewish people do not assimilate people easily into their culture, so it stays genetically pure. As far as markers go.

I said”I would not expect them to be able to find anything because DNA tracking does not work that way.”

Have you gone and looked at the site we were talking about? It was written by an actual geneticist, instead you are quoting..yourself.

The poster has thus implied that the Israelis are not finding what they are surely finding because the Israeli's methods are not making a connection to Native Americans for the LDS researchers who cannot find evidence to support Joe Smith's big lie. I think we have another dancing hamster ...

You have no manners. On this forum if you are going to denigrate someone in this case, me. It is customary to ping them to the post. In essence say that to my face.

That said, the Israelis were a closed pool, comparing with another closed pool (closed pool = people who did not marry outside of their group and genetic purity is important to them.) From these closed pools, remarkable finds were made by the very talented Geneticists in Israel.

The Indians were a promiscuous genetic people, and would marry anyone and kept no record of genealogy, thus connecting anything to them is hit or miss (mostly miss) To deny valid points in an argument and then running off and have a conversation behind your opponent’s back where you congratulate yourselves on your non-victory, well smacks of cowardice.

Please prove this impression wrong.