Posted on 04/11/2007 1:13:38 PM PDT by noname247
US FORCES in Baghdad are planning to seal off vast areas of the city with barricades, effectively imprisoning the inhabitants of neighbourhoods, according to The Independent.
"The campaign of 'gated communities' - whose genesis was in the Vietnam War - will involve up to 30 of the city's 89 official districts and would be the most ambitious counter-insurgency program yet mounted by the US in Iraq," wrote Robert Fisk.
The project to stop the movement of insurgents and weapons would involve joint US-Iraqi "support bases" in nine of the 30 districts to be "gated" off.
Militias would be cleared from civilian streets which would then be walled off and the occupants given ID cards.
Only the occupants would be allowed into these "gated communities" where there were likely to be pass systems, visitor registration and restrictions on movement outside. The plan, of which The Independent had learnt the details, was concocted by General David Petraeus, the US commander in Baghdad.
(Excerpt) Read more at news.com.au ...
Sounds like a reasonable plan.
It doesn’t sound like a bad idea considering how much middleasterners seem to love walls.
Gated communities, will some have swimming pools or golf courses?
In all seriousness, this makes sense. Leave it to the MSM to criticize our forces.
Right - no one had walls around their cities before that. But I'm from the MSM so I have to get "Vietnam" in somehow.
You’re on the right track.
“The campaign of ‘gated communities’ - whose genesis was in the Vietnam War “
The real “Genesis” was the British counterinsurgency in Malaya, which WORKED. The US borrowed the concept for South Vietnam but did not properly implement it.
How can walls be possible in Israel and Iraq but not in the US?
Good catch! Let's see, Joshua fought the battle of Jericho, and the (rain) came tumbling down? And don't forget the Great (Handball Court) of China.
ping
Compartmentalize?
Anyone know of recent historical examples?
too bad they can’t do that to OUR borders
No bias here.
Fisk is proof positive that there are some people that you can't even beat sense into.
They have some very nice gated communities like that in South Florida...
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7NzCg-oKVBk
See Flash Bazbeaux’s reference in #6 to Malaya. Many consider it the 20th Century ideal in counterisurgency ops, and it is frequently contrasted with the French failure(s) in Indochina.
We are making the SUNNI GHETTO right now. Just you watch and some democrat lunatic will accuse us of the same tactics the Nazis used in Warsaw 1943.
Well, they can’t let this sound like a “new strategy.”
That would impinge the “Bush can’t change” and “we must have a new course” (toward defeat) meme.
It works in LA, it ought to work in Baghdad.
Everything I’ve learned about the mideast over the last several years seems to indicate that they’ve already erected the walls on their own.
It’s a result of thousands of years of tribal warfare.
In this case it appears that all our military will be doing is erecting some barricades and checking IDs.
Oh, heck! Don’t give them any bright ideas, eh?
Of course, it is inevitable...
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.