[veronica]

I know several people who have had prostate cancer. Their treatment included surgery, chemo, and radiation. All of these forms of treatment were debilitating and impacted their functioning capacity for a time.

[Alberta's Child]

I don't even remember Rudy Giuliani missing a single public appearance due to his cancer treatments. And his hair fell out on its own over the years -- not due to the side effects of chemotherapy.

If Rudy Giuliani's illness were that serious, then we would have every reason to question whether or not he is physically capable of carrying out the duties of the nation's chief executive.

You can't have it both ways.