Are you going to answer the numerous questions?
Which one is better in your opinion (freedom calls is such an ironic name, btw) - Is it better when rudy violates the BOR as a mayor, or when he calls for the BOR to be violated at the federal level?
Each one of those situations (except the quartering -- Third Amendment) you gave has an amendment that has been "incorporated" per the Supreme Court. So no, according to the Supreme Court, Rudy couldn't violate those. The Second Amendment has never been judged to have been "incorporated" by the Supreme Court.