Posted on 12/29/2006 2:20:53 PM PST by JulieRNR21
TALLAHASSEE, Fla. - A judge ruled Friday that congressional aspirant Christine Jennings has no right to examine the programming source code that runs the electronic voting machines at the center of a disputed Southwest Florida congressional race.
Circuit Judge William Gary ruled that Jennings' arguments about the possibility of lost votes were "conjecture," and didn't warrant overriding the trade secrets of the voting machine company.
Democrats in Congress meanwhile, said they'd allow Republican Vern Buchanan to take the seat next Thursday, but with a warning that the inquiry wasn't over and that his hold on it could be temporary.
The state has certified Buchanan the winner of the District 13 race by a scant 369 votes.
The ruling Friday from Judge Gary prevents for now the Jennings camp from being able to use the programming code to try to show voting machines used in Sarasota County malfunctioned. Jennings claims that an unusually large number of undervotes - ballots that didn't show a vote - recorded in the race implies the machines lost the votes.
"The judge has reaffirmed that there is no merit to Christine Jennings' baseless allegations that the voting machines malfunctioned," Buchanan spokeswoman Sally Tibbetts said in a statement released by his campaign. "As noted by the judge in today's ruling, two parallel tests conducted by the state revealed '100 percent accuracy of the equipment in reporting the vote selections.'"
Reggie Mitchell, a lawyer for People for the American Way, a group working with the Jennings campaign in challenging the election results, said the judge's decision would likely be appealed.
"We'd like to get (the code) and prove our case as opposed to listening to the state and (the voting machine company's) theories," Mitchell said.
Jennings still has a complaint filed before Congress, which is the ultimate arbiter of who will fill the seat. The seat is being vacated by Rep. Katherine Harris, a Republican who unsuccessfully ran for the Senate.
"The House has the power to collect evidence and make a decision about who, if anyone, was duly elected to represent the people of the 13th district," U.S. Rep. Rush Holt, D-N.J., said Friday before the judge's ruling. Holt plans to make an official statement next week making it clear that by seating Buchanan, the House isn't forfeiting the right to reverse that decision later.
"No one who is in a disputed election like this should get too comfortable in the House of Representatives," Holt said in a news conference at the Capitol.
But that was before Gary put a dent in Jennings' plans with his ruling Friday, in which he said that testimony by experts for Jennings about how unlikely it was that voters would have chosen to simply skip the race was merely "conjecture."
Drew Hammill, a spokesman for incoming House Speaker Nancy Pelosi, D-Calif., said that the judge's ruling Friday didn't change plans by the House to investigate the election, and also noted that the ruling isn't final because Jennings can appeal.
But Democrats have no plans to block Buchanan from taking the seat, deciding the people of the southwest Florida district should have representation while the contest is being decided, Hammill said.
"This is the best way to maintain representation for Florida District 13 while allowing the two appropriate challenges to run their course," said Hammill.
Jennings said she agreed.
"I think it's the right thing to do, to seat Vern Buchanan temporarily while we gather evidence," Jennings said before Gary's ruling. "But I am pursuing this and I do believe I will end up being the representative for the people of the 13th District."
Neither Jennings nor her lawyers could be immediately reached following Gary's ruling.
Holt said Democrats were sending a message that the winner of the seat should be decided deliberately.
"This is not going to be a Congress where procedural matters are determined by brute force," he said. But, he said he believed the evidence would show that the vote was marred and there was a good possibility Jennings would ultimately be seated.
The electronic touch-screen machines used in Sarasota County are at the center of the challenge.
Some 18,000 Sarasota County electronic ballots did not register a vote in the race, a much higher undervote rate - nearly 15 percent - than in others such as those for governor or U.S. Senate. Jennings contends the machines lost the votes. Buchanan backers and the company say that if there was an unusually large undervote it was likely because of bad ballot design.
The state found no evidence of malfunctions in the machines, which were made by Election Systems & Software.
For Immediate Release Contact: Sally Tibbetts December 29, 2006 941.953.6060
Judge Rules Jennings’ Lawsuit Based on “Conjecture” and “Speculation”
Sarasota, Florida – The Buchanan campaign released the following statement today regarding Judge William Gray’s finding that defeated congressional candidate Christine Jennings’ lawsuit is based on “conjecture” and “speculation” and that her claims are “not supported by credible evidence.”
“In his ruling, the Judge has reaffirmed that there is no merit to Christine Jennings’ baseless allegations that the voting machines malfunctioned,” said spokeswoman Sally Tibbetts. “As noted by the Judge in today’s ruling, two parallel tests conducted by the state revealed ‘100% accuracy of the equipment in reporting the vote selections’. The state last week concluded that the machines used in the election accurately recorded every vote.” ____________________________
VERN BUCHANAN FOR U.S. CONGRESS
For Immediate Release Contact: Sally Tibbetts December 29, 2006 941.953.6060
The Buchanan campaign released the following statement today regarding Christine Jennings’ press conference.
“This confirms what the people of Florida’s 13th District already know, that Vern Buchanan is the certified winner of the election and that he will be seated,” said spokeswoman Sally Tibbetts. “We look forward to Congressman-elect Vern Buchanan being sworn-in and going to work on behalf of the people of this district.
“There is nothing in statute, House rules, or the Constitution that provides a special condition for the seating of a Member of Congress,” added Tibbetts. “All Members are seated equally. All members are sworn in for the duration of the Congress unless they resign or the House votes to remove them.”
Tibbetts concluded, “It is unfortunate that Jennings will continue with her groundless lawsuit built on the false premise that the machines malfunctioned. After two rounds of tests, the state has concluded the machines accurately recorded every vote that was cast.”
what do they think the source code will show?
she wanted undervotes counted for her, it was that simple.
Latest on the Dems attempt tp steal Florida Dictrict 13 Congressional seat......
Please ping your lists.
The dems lost Johnson's vote and the republicans gain Buchanan!
Sarasota County is full of Republicans. 18,000 no votes is very common. These rats... just beyond words. I bet they WOULD LOVE to get their hands on this code. Kudos to Judge Gary.
Oops. Gary = Gray
Cheers!
Don't you just hate it when judges stick to the law?
That sure in an unusual response to a man in a coma.
People for the American Way, a blast from the past.
Not to mention the 25,000 undervotes in the 2000 congressional race won by Dan Miller. Jennings should have been toast a long time ago. We'll see if the dems are serious about not being the culture of corruption...or at least not appearing that way, yet.
Many out of Florida radical left Dem groups like PAW and MoveOn.org have been funding Jennings' lawsuit just as they funded her campaign!
IOW only the Imperial Republic of Florida gets to inspect the machines to determine why the undervote was over 14% in Sarasota County compared with 1-3% in the other counties, all of which had basically the same ballots.
This result is BS which will surely be reversed after the voting machines are inspected by experts who are not agents of the Imperial Republic of Florida.
Care to add my full post or are you a spinner for the dems.
see my response below.
Perhaps Buchanan pissed off more people in Sarasota than elsewhere.
Why didn't this happen in counties where Dems won? It comfirms their beliefs, if they lose, elections were stolen and if they win, the system works....
I believe this is the first call for a recount and of course it is from a Democrat. Republicans take the vote as it appears and walk away............Democrats will sue or disrupt over anything that isn't in their favor - Pelosi says the 'investigation' will continue.
Judge William L. Gary denied Jennings' motions in the 2nd Judicial Circuit Court by saying that 'the testimony of the Plaintiff's experts was nothing more than conjecture and not supported by credible evidence.'
Judge Gary's ruling also stated that 'test results revealed 100% accuracy of the equipment in reporting the vote selections,' and that the Jennings campaign and the liberal activist groups who have been supporting her legal case "have presented no evidence to demonstrate that the parallel testing was flawed.'
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.