How was this different then the crazy rabbi who was going to sue in Seattle to either take down the Christmas trees or put up the menorah?
Just asking, not trying to be facetious.
It's exactly the same. Couldn't he have found a church yard or private property for the creche? Same for the Menorah.
I'd say the Christmas tree is a Christmas symbol, but not a religious one. It's not a "pagan" symbol anymore, but neither does it commemorate the birth of Christ.
I think the trees, lights, wreaths and decorations on public property are more aimed at making a festive atmosphere to encourage shopping, not exactly the meaning of Christmas (or Hanukkah either).
The town govt was correct. The fellow, well meaning, just like the rabbi at the airport, should have left well enough alone. Let the tree represent joy Christmas, and let the menorah represent the celebration of miracle of Hanukkah.
The Rabbi never asked for the generic Holiday Trees (Sea-Tac's name) to be taken down, he wanted them up, but he wanted a Menorah too.