I read and responded to your post. Apparently you couldn't discern my response.
I guess it is ok to let people get obese on burgers and fries but not let them smoke off duty (a totally legal substance). They can therefore do anything else detrimential to their health, but please don't have a legal cigarette.
I read an article in the 70's from National Geographic. They were looking for common dominators from people in the world who were were 100 years and older. What did these people have in common?
Some still smoked....which should thrill idiot employers. The common theme was 1200 callories a day of low fat foods.
You've given reasons why this could be a bad decision by Scotts, but you've failed to give a good reason why the courts need to intervene to stop it.