PING!
Posted on 11/28/2006 7:15:50 AM PST by GMMAC
Edward I goes to Ramadi
Despite all the bad news from Iraq, some U.S. tactics are working.
Michael Fumento reports on one of them: the Combat Operation Post
Michael Fumento, Embedded with 1st Brigade Combat Team
National Post
Tuesday, November 28, 2006
RAMADI, Iraq - The capital of Iraq's Al Anbar province, Ramadi, remains for U.S. troops the most violent city in Iraq. Yet we seem finally to be gaining ground there against the insurgents and al-Qaeda terrorists. And COPs -- Combat Operation Posts -- may be one of the most important reasons.
Historically, successful counterinsurgency efforts have involved pacifying areas by plopping small garrisons with interlocking communications into enemy territory and sending out patrols to gather information and engage the enemy. Perhaps the most famous example is provided by King Edward I of England (the guy who gutted Braveheart), who used castles to consolidate his hold on Wales in the late 13th-century.
More recently, U.S. Army Special Forces established Civilian Irregular Defence Group camps in South Vietnam, manned primarily by indigenous tribes or South Vietnamese with a core of Special Forces soldiers.
These were considered one of the most effective strategies of that war.
There's no set size for a COP, but in the Ramadi area it's an undersized company of four platoons, or about 80 soldiers. First Brigade Combat Team, which overseas Coalition Forces in Ramadi, put in 11 COPs so far and is going to install more. The first in Ramadi was created in June. These garrisons are tiny offshoots from much-larger forward operating bases (FOBs), which have about 1,000 men. The COP in which I was embedded, COP Anvil in northern Ramadi, comprises just two concrete houses commandeered and leased from Iraqi civilians.
Anvil is commanded by Captain Don Sapp of A Company, 1/6. It has an oversized company of more than 120 men from three American platoons and one Iraqi platoon. Anvil also has four M-2 Bradley fighting vehicles attached to it, giving it real firepower. Anvil also draws support from Forward Operating Base Blue Diamond, which in turn draws support from Camp Ramadi.
The military refers to COP use as "the inkblot strategy." One dot spreads into a bigger spot. Further, the troops are practically forced to work with the locals. That means building up networks of indigenous people who know the terrain, culture and locals better than soldiers ever could. They can even pick out those Iraqis who come from out of province. All of this creates a force multiplier. Since we simply don't have enough troops in the Anbar, this ability to make better use of troops without weakening the forward operating bases from which they're drawn is vital.
Another value of the Ramadi COPs over the FOBs and Camp Ramadi is that we're fighting an enemy that relies primarily on improvised explosive devices (IEDs) -- bombs planted on the side of the road, vehicle-borne IEDs, suicide-vehicle-borne IEDs -- to inflict casualties and damage, with the potential for greatly restricting movement. But missions from COPs are short-range; you're always almost there. That's less road to be on and hence fewer explosives and ambushes to worry about. COPs also have no chance of being overrun both because of the inability of the enemy to fight skillfully or mass in large numbers, and because of the COPs' multilayered defences.
Anvil has concertina barbed wire and HESCO baskets as an inner layer of protection. A HESCO is a huge thick bag in a wire mesh into which sand or dirt can be dumped. Linked together, the bags form an extremely effective blast wall and an impregnable barrier.
Sapp took advantage of Anvil's rural location to cut down vegetation surrounding his two buildings, creating unobstructed line of sight for targeting attackers.
Ingress over irrigation canals is controlled with concertina wire in some of the canals and by knocking down numerous foot bridges and replacing them with fewer easily-watched ones.
Two men are always on top of the American-occupied building (the Iraqi army controls the other structure) to survey the countryside. They have access to an anti-armour rocket, a Mark-19 40 mm automatic grenade launcher and a .50 caliber M8A1A. One .50 caliber shot into an engine block can stop a vehicle in its tracks. You don't want to hear what it can do to a human being. Sapp showed me the impact of the Combat Operation Post system in Ramadi (Fallujah also has some) on a map. The foreign fighters who come into this area do so along the main highway from the Syrian border to the west.
It's a mini-Ho Chi Minh Trail, so to speak. From this road, the terrorists used to fan out in the area where the COPs have been inserted. "In the last four months, we've kept pushing them right around here," Sapp indicated, with his finger moving in a counter-clockwise pattern.
"Initially we wouldn't go anywhere in this area with anything less than a platoon and sometimes even armour," he said. "But now I allow them to enter with just squads." The only part of the fan still remaining pushes the enemy against the Euphrates River.
At Anvil, almost all missions are on foot and off the trails. That's part of the beauty of the COP system; you can go almost anywhere you need stealthily. The night I was there we set off to grab some of bin Laden's buddies.
The targets were in two houses about 400 metres away from the COP, and the best avenue of approach would be through a series of irrigation canals and the offshoot ditches. This canal system would prove my undoing. Jumping from little strips of land to other little strips is an acquired skill. You don't acquire it in one night and I fell into a canal and destroyed my camcorder and voice recorder. It was interesting going out in the sunlight afterwards and seeing how treacherous the terrain really was. "I hate that night s--t," a soldier told me.
But the raid couldn't have gone better. We struck the jackpot in the form of an al-Qaeda intelligence officer whose chief job was assassinating Iraqi police. He was perhaps 22 years old. As soon as the plastic cuffs were on him he faked heart problems and then breathing problems. I guess he thought the soft-hearted Amerikani would just let him go. Tough luck, bad boy. We also grabbed two other potential suspects. We brought them back and put them in an outdoor holding pen. Both later admitted to being al-Qaeda fighters.
Three terrorists in one night is a nice haul and it's vastly better than simply killing them. They will expose others who may in turn expose yet others -- with no civilian "collateral damage." As with COPs, it's how the Coalition is taking back Ramadi and restoring hope to its citizens -- one little step at a time.
Michael Fumento is a Washington-based writer who has been embedded in Al Anbar province three times, and Ramadi twice.
A more detailed account of his tour in Ramadi can be found in the Nov. 27 issue of the Weekly Standard.
fumento@pobox.com
© National Post 2006
PING!
Good work, Michael. Who knew you were so brave? (No sarcasm intended.)
He is Honourably Discharged from the United States Army.
It sounds like this is a plus in this sunni region.
So....is there or will there be the same in shia areas?
If so, how would helping both sides be perceived?
and an aside......how about sunni/al qaeda types and hezzie/shia types masquerading within these groups?
and another....."insurgents"....what a joke of a designation, exploited by all who have a dog in this fight.
So we want to "talk" to Iran and Syria?
And we want to get "help" (for the sunnies????) from other sunni countries simultaneously????
Geez, I can't keep up with all this shiite.....its splattering all over the place too fast from the fan! (fan rhymes with iran)
I guess I've finally found out where the REAL journalists (or at least one) went after the hippies took over the craft down here in the states.
My only caveat: You may be overly charitable when you class the Washington Times as "philosophical" or conservative.
I will always think that there's some remainder of the old swampland inside the Beltway that sucks all the brains and balls out of anyone who stays in the area too long.
Here's Fumentos rundown of who's who.....
Patriquin and Lee described how coalition forces break down the "anti-Iraqi forces"--the forces opposing the elected government of Iraq--into four categories.
First there are the unaffiliated foreign fighters.
Second is al Qaeda in Iraq, comprising both local and foreign terrorists.
Third are local resistance fighters who are generally disgruntled ex-Baathists trying to get back the good life.
Fourth are organized criminals and smugglers who are just in it for the bucks.
(taken from his current Weekly Standard piece here:
http://www.weeklystandard.com/Content/Public/Articles/000/000/012/985qugel.asp?pg=2
Sure sounds like a full-blown civil war, doesn't it?
(I'd add a note here about /sarc/, but it has become redundant whenever discussion of the MSM is involved. As if I need to tell YOU that.)
these 4 categories disregard shia/hezbollah and Iran. If there are really any CIDG/RFPF's in the big picture, they are surely in northeast Iraq, Northern Iran, and SE Turkey, LOL.
What a friggin mess it seems to be. The Vn analogy has surely become valid only or at least in the sense that poli-sci majors are once again running the festivities, yes?
"The Vn analogy has surely become valid only or at least in the sense that poli-sci majors are once again running the festivities, yes?"
IMHO, the politicians are no more in charge now than they were in 1968: The only things concerning most of those bums is cocktail party invitations and making sure that they don't miss the prime taxpayer-paid junkets.
The MSM is doing the same thing with Iraq/WOT that they did in the 60's & 70's to SE Asia. THEY have the agenda, THEY have control of the information and THEY think that they're the ones in charge. Only joker in the deck is if Bush and people like us let them get away with that crap again.
I'm already locked and loaded. Have been for d*** years.
Sounds like W is in about the same mood, and the next couple of weeks could be MOST interesting.
emotionally overwrought, casualty count obsessed, defeatist drivel the msm generally sees fit to publish.
Three terrorists in one night is a nice haul and it's vastly better than simply killing them. They will expose others who may in turn expose yet others -- with no civilian "collateral damage." As with COPs, it's how the Coalition is taking back Ramadi and restoring hope to its citizens -- one little step at a time
I dunno, sounds pretty bleeding heart to me. Then again, I personally have had a chip on my shoulder since Stanfield lost, and my people have been fighting the moon-worshippers since the 8th century.
bttt
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.