Posted on 11/11/2006 8:19:55 AM PST by Graybeard58
PROVIDENCE, R.I. -- Sen. Lincoln Chafee said his knees buckled when he walked into his polling place Tuesday morning and saw that voters were given a prominently displayed option of casting votes along a straight-party line.
"It was so easy to just go against the Republicans and fill in that Democrat. It was so easy," Chafee said Thursday in a post-mortem dissection of his loss to Democrat Sheldon Whitehouse.
Voters in Rhode Island did exactly that on Tuesday, filling in Democrats in large numbers and sweeping the Republican Chafee from office as part of a fierce backlash that uprooted GOP incumbents across the country.
Rhode Island is in the minority of states where voters can select candidates entirely from the same party with just a single mark or punch on their ballots. The straight party option is available in just over a dozen states, largely in the south and the Midwest.
"I don't know that there's a good or a bad or a right or a wrong," said Kathleen Dolan, a political science professor at the University of Wisconsin-Milwaukee who is originally from Rhode Island. "It depends on your perspective."
Though political parties may favor the option as a way to entrench their power in states where they dominate, critics say it can discourage thoughtful voting by allowing citizens to cast purely partisan votes without deciding on individual races or for individual candidates.
"Every voter ought to look at each race that he or she is voting for," said Richard Winger, editor of Ballot Access News, a California-based publication. "It just takes away from thinking."
The Rhode Island Board of Elections says 61,000 voters cast a straight-party ballot for the Democrats by connecting an arrow at the top of their ballot. The number of straight-party ballots for Republican candidates was more than 18,300, according to the elections board.
Republican Gov. Don Carcieri was the lone member of his party elected to state office, and even he survived a closer-than-expected fight.
The option is a carry-over from lever machines the state used until a decade ago.
"The law was written to ensure that the equipment would allow for the same kind of straight-party voting," said Peter Kerwin, a spokesman for the secretary of state's office.
But the number of states with the option has been declining.
Missouri eliminated straight-ticket voting this year, and Illinois abolished it in the late 1990s. The Kentucky secretary of state proposed getting rid of the option this year, but the idea stalled in the state legislature.
"It's something that we're going to continue to push for," said Les Fugate, a spokesman for the office. "It's not going away."
David Kimball, a political science professor at the University of Missouri-St. Louis, said party-line voting tends to be more convenient for voters and yields more residual votes in races located farther down on the ballot -- which typically receive less attention and publicity.
On the other hand, he added, voters may think they're done after casting a straight-party vote and then fail to mark their preferences on ballot initiatives.
"Of course, it's a political hotball," said Megan Mullin, an assistant political science professor at Temple University in Philadelphia,
She said she doubted Chafee's loss could be attributed simply to party-line voting, especially since the race got so much publicity and because a Republican governor was able to win re-election.
The typical casualty of straight-party voting would be a lesser-known candidate whose race is listed lower on the ballot.
"Is it possible that Chafee lost a few votes because of the party vote? Absolutely," Mullin said, but later added, "I find it hard to believe that the effect of the party ballot was enough to take the Senate seat away from Lincoln Chafee."
What I said is blindly voting straight ticket Republican is idiotic and people should decide on the races individually. Chafee is deserving of ZERO support from Republicans. Time and money used to help Chafee could have been better spent helping Talent, Allen, Burns, and Steele. Instead people wanted to endorse Chafee's re-election solely because he had an "R" next to his name.
The powers that be in the GOP should be neutral in a primary, but THEY donated plenty of time and effort to derail Steve Laffey so that POS Linc Chafee was renominated. Chafee was NOT the choice of the GOP voters and wouldn't have won the primary without outside interferance. Once Chafee was shoved down our throats in the primary, we should have abanonded him and went to work for decent Republicans deserving of our support. If we had done so, we'd still control the Senate today.
The ONLY conservative newspaper in PA that I know of is the Tribune Review owned by Scaife, the gazillionaire the Democrats accused of running some kind of stealth campaign to smear (the Arkansas Project) Clinton. He owns a bunch of little papers in a ring around P'burgh in addition to the T-R, but he certainly doesn't hire the editorial or news staff of any of them from the looks of them. He is slowly but surely putting the toxic Post-Gazette, the only remaining P'burgh city paper out of business, but nobody, neither conservative nor liberal, is much interested in buying newspapers. It won't be long until most graduates coming out of the public schools will not be able to read well enough to understand a news article, so that's understandable.
"Show me just what Mohammed brought that was new, and there you will find things only evil and inhuman, such as his command to spread by the sword the faith he preached." -Manuel II Paleologus
That's actually not Chafee's problem, unfortunately. He had 60 something % approval ratings.
It's just that RI is a nutcase D state and they wanted a nutcase D, not a nutcase R.
Straight party balloting killed the GOP in NH, too. Lynch was strong at the top of the ticket and people here hated Bush so much that the NH House and Senate Dem candidates were swept in after beating long-time GOP officials of all political persuasions (from very conservative to very liberal, so there was no real rhyme or reason to booting all of them out) and it killed Bradley and Bass (Bradley, moreso). No one who studies state politics expected the landslide win for Democrats in the House and Senate, even though many believed both houses would go Dem. It was the proverbial tsunami that analysts were talking about on the national scale in congressional races that didn't exactly happen.
Republican Gov. Don Carcieri was the lone member of his party elected to state office, and even he survived a closer-than-expected fight.
Carcieri is known for standing up to the Democrat legislature and demanding fiscal responsibility. In short, the conservative in this election survived.
Regards, Ivan
Senator Chafee: Just go away, putz.
Funny how in Florida, Democrats called this "politicking" in the Foley-Negron district.
-PJ
Were they reacting to the Christian wing of the GOP or the war in Iraq?
Amen.
LOL.
A bit of both, but mostly Iraq-- 9/10ths Iraq. New Hampshire voters hate everything about George W. Bush. He couldn't win a race for dog catcher here.
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.