"Treading water" means that you've made no new accomplishments. I mention this because you clearly don't know what the phrase represents.
Passing tax cuts into law, killing Kyoto and the CCCP-U.S. ABM treaty, jailing Saddam Hussein, banning partial birth abortion, and deploying missile defenses (land, air, and sea-based) is not, by any stretch of the educated mind, somehow "treading water."
So yes, you are asking for too much. You are asking for things that can not be, or in denial of what has already been.