Skip to comments.
Angelides calls border fence wrong
Sacramento Bee ^
| 10/5/6
| Peter Hecht
Posted on 10/05/2006 8:11:04 AM PDT by SmithL
Angelides says he doesn't favor building a big wall to keep illegal immigrants out.
Phil Angelides says he doesn't favor erecting "a Great Wall of China" to keep illegal immigrants out of California, adding that he would take a "compassionate and pragmatic" approach as governor to the politically volatile immigration issue.
In a meeting with The Bee editorial board Wednesday, the Democratic gubernatorial candidate said he favors granting driver's licenses to illegal immigrants because doing so would make California's roads safer.
And he said he would have signed a recent bill -- vetoed by Gov. Arnold Schwarzenegger -- to allow illegal immigrants to receive financial assistance to attend California's universities.
In a wide-ranging interview, Angelides also said he still believes he can win the gubernatorial race despite trailing by as much as 17 percent in recent polls.
He defended his campaign's attempt to link the Republican governor and his policies to President Bush, a decidedly unpopular figure with California voters. And he said he is counting on Saturday's gubernatorial debate to put him back into the race.
While espousing compassion on immigration, Angelides chided Schwarzenegger for not being tough enough to convince the federal government to reimburse California for nearly $750 million for the incarceration costs of illegal immigrants.
He also said California has been shortchanged by the Bush administration's failure to meet a post-Sept. 11, 2001, promise of providing 2,000 new U.S. Border Patrol agents a year.
"A governor ought to be rolling up his or her sleeves and demanding, cajoling and working with the federal government to get them to live up to their responsibilities," Angelides said.
Schwarzenegger campaign spokesman Matt David scoffed at the suggestion that Angelides could do better.
"The notion that Phil Angelides and his partisan rhetoric would return more money to California is absurd," David said.
(Excerpt) Read more at sacbee.com ...
TOPICS: Culture/Society; Front Page News; Government; News/Current Events; Politics/Elections; US: California
KEYWORDS: aliens; angelides; illegalimmigrant; immigrantlist; pandering
Navigation: use the links below to view more comments.
first previous 1-20, 21-29 last
To: SmithL
Even the Democrats I know can't stand Angelides. I swear he is actually a Republican ringer, he couldn't be any worse if he tried. One person said he can suck the oxygen out of a room
21
posted on
10/05/2006 12:30:15 PM PDT
by
RedStateRocker
(Nuke Mecca, Deport all illegals, abolish the IRS, ATF and DEA)
To: SmithL
In a meeting with The Bee editorial board Wednesday, the Democratic gubernatorial candidate said he favors granting driver's licenses to illegal immigrants because doing so would make California's roads safer.I love the logic of the "safer roads" argument:
A. Illegals drive without licenses anyway
B. If we gave them licenses, they'll have to learn the rules so that they can be issued one, therefore the roads will be safer.
If we believe (B), then we have to believe that, once licenses are possible, an illegal won't drive if he fails the test and can't get one. However, we already have evidence that that isn't going to happen: see (A).
What we'll really get is every illegal who's afraid to drive without a license today will suddenly be able to get one, putting God knows how many new drivers (many driving 'inexpensive' clunkers with bald tires, questionable brakes, and no insurance) on our clogged roads.
22
posted on
10/05/2006 1:35:16 PM PDT
by
John Jorsett
(scam never sleeps)
To: SmithL
Well, Angelides is doing better than the normal Liberal moron. The wall is a bad idea. However, as soon as he starts babbling about "compassion" and "pragmatism" I have to suppress a reflex to barf.
What really pisses me off is that this piece of political doodoo got thru Congress instead of meaningful legislation that will make a difference. What REALLY gets my dander up is that the Great American Doormat signed the thing into law yesterday rather than vetoing it and beating up on Congress for sending him frivolous legislation.
So, Congress in its infinite wisdom is going to solve our immigration problems with a 700-mile fence!? Seven hundred miles of fence to cover a 2,000 mile border while we conveniently forget about little details like boats and coastlines! A $1.2 billion dollar monument to political cowardice! GRRRR!
You don't kill a market by blocking supply. You stop a market by drying up demand! Any attempt to seal the borders of the United States against illegal immigrants is doomed to costly failure! The Soviet Union used fences, walls, barbed wire, guard towers, land mines, guard dogs, and machine-guns to keep its people in and was unsuccessful! I know the US will never be equally draconian and so I am certain this 700 mile fence will inevitably and expensively fail.
We have a deluge of illegal immigrants trying to cross our borders and, consequently, a serious security problem! Herds of impoverished illegals overwhelm our border patrols and provide excellent cover for the small number of criminals and terrorists who wish to do us harm. Dry up demand for illegals and soon our border guards will only have to worry about our enemies.
Instead of a fancy fence, we should have a genuine guest worker program that meets the honest needs of our economy while allowing guest workers to keep as much of their dignity as possible and while protecting them from de-facto slavery under unscrupulous employers.
Most importantly, US employers who willfully ignore or subvert the provisions of guest worker laws should be subject to SEVERE penalties. Hiring illegal aliens should be a felony offense that guarantees employers and corporate officers JAIL time and HEAVY fines.
It must be difficult for illegal immigrants to stay in the shadows of our society. Illegal immigrants must not be able to obtain drivers licenses and access to the social safety net that is available to citizens and legal immigrants. Meals and schooling for children and emergency medical care is the VERY most that illegals should be entitled to. Employees of US government agencies (except for the Census Bureau) that fail to investigate for evidence of illegals and provide that evidence to the INS for action should be immediately and irrevocably FIRED from their government jobs.
Those who smuggle foreign nationals into the U.S. should be subject to the most severe penalties up to capital punishment in cases where people die in the course of being smuggled into the U.S.
Simply being born in this country should not entitle anyone to US citizenship unless at least one (and preferably both) parents are here LEGALLY!
Oh, for some good Libertarian or Teddy Roosevelt Republican candidates! I'm sick and tired of these bleeping Dimocrats and Repisslican candidates that I have to pick from! The most irritating thing about both the Dimocrats and Repisslicans is that as soon as they get to DC they get a chocolate eclair for a spinal transplant and an (empty) piggy bank for a brain transplant!
Boy, this was a long one! Sure feels good to get it off my chest, tho.
23
posted on
10/05/2006 3:07:03 PM PDT
by
lechtellhavel
(Giving money and power to govt is like giving whiskey and car keys to teenage boys.-PJ O'Rourke)
To: Blue Turtle
Exactly.
Angelides is clueless or a traitor. The compassionate thing to do to the taxpayers would be to deport the illegals. President Eisenhower deported millions of them and no reason why it cannot be done again.
24
posted on
10/05/2006 3:10:32 PM PDT
by
Dante3
To: lechtellhavel
I think that your post 23, especially the part about penalties for those who break our laws, makes a lot of sense. I, too, have thought that the employers (and you know who you are) should tremble at the thought of signing off on the paycheck of someone who they are not absolutely convinced is a citizen or legal immigrant.
This second paragraph is not about your post, but when I read those posts about drivers licenses for those not in this country legally, I shudder. I think you Californians and residents of other states impacted by such concerns are very brave when you get behind the wheels of your cars and trucks. Luckily, I live in a state (and in a rural area, to boot) where we don't worry about that. Whew!
I know that there are many reasons why you live where you do, but if I were you I would think about getting out of there if at all possible.
To: lechtellhavel
Any attempt to seal the borders of the United States against illegal immigrants is doomed to costly failure!
Oh, come on - we'll just use the techniques that have worked so well to stem the flow of drugs!
/sarc
26
posted on
10/05/2006 9:06:12 PM PDT
by
RedStateRocker
(Nuke Mecca, Deport all illegals, abolish the IRS, ATF and DEA)
To: goldstategop
"Phil Angelides thinks illegal aliens are popular with California voters. He has forgotten Gray Davis was recalled, among other things, for signing a bill granting illegals drivers' licenses that was subsequently repealed by the voters in a referendum. His opposition to a border fence reveals he is out of touch with mainstream Californians on the issue of immigration."
Exactly...thank god I don't think he has much of a chance of getting elected....all California needs is another snake-in-the-grass like Tony Villa-"LaRaza"...our anti-American LA mayor....
27
posted on
10/05/2006 9:14:33 PM PDT
by
Niteflyr
("People get the leaders they deserve" (hear that Mexico??))
To: gubamyster
lol, ok the fence/wall is wrong, so what
he is out of touch with more than 80% of our citizens.
To: lechtellhavel
What amazes me is how so many folks here equate "guest worker" with "amnesty", and verifiable ID with "government intrusion".
Both of these are key to stopping economically motivated illegal immigration. Stop demand, and the need for expensive walls reduced to a more realistic role as regulators of legal traffic.
29
posted on
10/07/2006 1:08:06 PM PDT
by
Wiseghy
("You want to break this army? Then break your word to it.")
Navigation: use the links below to view more comments.
first previous 1-20, 21-29 last
Disclaimer:
Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual
posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its
management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the
exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.
FreeRepublic.com is powered by software copyright 2000-2008 John Robinson