Posted on 09/25/2006 12:30:48 PM PDT by Hannibal Hamlin
Deputies crash home, shoot dog, seeking man already in their jail
Tue, 08/29/2006 - 5:57pm
By: Ben Nelms
Deputies crash home, shoot dog, seeking man already in their jail
It was a case where the officer said he was doing his job, and the homeowner said it was excessive. During the Aug. 21 incident, a 12-year-old dog in its accustomed place on its back porch was shot in the mouth during an attempt by Fayette County Sheriffs deputies to serve a warrant at a Fayetteville residence on a man already in the Fayette County Jail.
The incident began as Fayette sheriffs deputies and officers from the Warrant Division arrived shortly after 6 p.m. Aug. 21 at the North Jeff Davis home of Brian and Yvette Tilton to serve a Clayton County warrant on Michael Horton, the brother of Yvette Tilton.
The problem was that Horton was not at the residence. He was in Fayette County Jail, where he had been since Tilton turned him into authorities back in May.
Unaware of the fact that the man they sought was already behind bars at their own jail, deputies went to the front and back doors of the residence in their attempt to locate Horton.
As Deputy Ryan Phillips rounded the back of the house near the steps to the back porch, he said in his statement that he was charged by the Tiltons large Catahoula, Jasper.
It was then that Phillips shot the dog under the chin. The bullet shattered the dogs left jaw and teeth and damaged the upper teeth. The animal survived but later had extensive surgery on its jaw.
Upon my arrival, Sgt. Vickery and D/S Mindar went to the front door as I went toward the back door, due to Mr. Hortons history of flight and obstruction, Phillips report said.
As I reached the northeast corner of the residence, I encountered a large canine (later identified as a Catahoula breed) growling and charging me front the back porch of the home, Phillips said.
The dog was unsecured by fence or leash. As the dog was approximately six feet from me, I drew my duty weapon and fired one round into the animal. The dog immediately retreated and ran back onto the back porch. I then holstered my weapon and went to check on the animals well-being, the deputy said.
A renter at the residence, Erik Wagner, was present during the incident. Wagner said he overheard two unidentified deputies talking about the shooting after the incident, with one of the deputies saying, The dog stood up and growled, so I shot him. That statement differs from Phillips statement on the Aug. 21 Supplemental Report.
Though he could not identify the officers by name, Wagner said he spoke with two of the officers after the incident, asking if they carried pepper spray. Wagner said he was told that deputies did carry the spray.
I asked, Why didnt you use it? but there was no answer, Wagner said.
Commenting on the incident, Yvette Tilton said Jasper had been seen by a vet and would wear a protective brace for several months. Blood stains were still evident on the back porch, splattered approximately three to eight feet from the back door and approximately six feet from the steps leading down to the northeast side of the house.
Tilton said Jasper had attacked a person only once before, 10 years ago when someone threw rocks through the fence and entered the yard. Today, Jasper will charge at another dog but not at people, she insisted.
Beyond the shooting of her dog, Tilton said she was also concerned by the way her family was treated.
Im concerned about cops on my porch with drawn guns. Weve been nothing but cooperative with the cops both times I turned my brother in for breaking the law, Tilton said. Were law-abiding and we dont bother anybody. With guns drawn on my porch, it makes me feel like we were treated like a threat to society. Its just the opposite reason why we moved here. We moved here to have a safe place to live and raise our kids.
Her brother is still in the Fayette County jail on three charges: theft by receiving, possession of marijuana (less than one ounce) and interfering with police.
The dog, after veterinary treatment, is recovering on his back porch.
power corrupts....
Nevermind
Good thing they came in guns blazin' for such an obviously dangerous criminal.
Sounds like a deputy wanted everyone to know how big a wee-wee he's got.
Another example of why the police should not be allowed the power of a no knock warrant.
Leopard dogs, they are beautiful animals that are very protective. Hope they cover all the bills for this guy's poor dog.
carolyn
Another article on
Shot dogs owner surprised by support
Tue, 09/05/2006 - 5:08pm
By: Ben Nelms
http://www.thecitizen.com/node/9990
Why does it seem they always shoot the dog? Is that just standard procedure these days?
I supervised a warrant squad for about one year. If this story is accurate, there is no excuse for this sort of buffoonery.
I hope that the S/O is doing it's best to make things right by at least paying the vet bills.
Hopefully the cop will get the same treatment one day.
"He was in Fayette County Jail, where he had been since Tilton turned him into authorities back in May."
No good deed goes unpunished.
That is a cool looking dog. Thanks for posting the pic, you read my inquiring mind.
The way this article reads, they had to go through a fence to get to house. Did he expect dog owners to have their dog fenced inside a fence, or leashed in the yard? I support LEOs but some of them are just a**holes and/or cowards.
The bottom line is, they didn't need to be their in the first place. Stupidity on the part of the police force caused this.
If they did pull the record should it not show that he was in jail at the time?
The typical Catahoula is uglier than dirt--I'd never use the term "beautiful" on one. They have "character" in the same sense that a bulldog does. Good cow and pig dogs, though. And the photo doesn't have the "one yellow and one blue" eye that is very characteristic of the breed.
My neighbor across the road when I was growing up in South Louisiana always had Catahoulas.
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.