Posted on 09/15/2006 9:49:05 AM PDT by JSedreporter
College administrators are scratching their heads trying to figure our how the straight-A students they accepted tanked on the SATs. “The University of California system, for instance, reported a 15-point drop in applicants’ scores but no corresponding dips in other measures of their quality, such as class rank and grade-point average,” Eric Hoover reports in the September 8th issue of the Chronicle of Higher Education. “At La Salle University in Philadelphia, SAT scores fell an average of 15 points for applicants and about 10 points for admitted students even though officials had not altered their admissions strategies.”
“Robert G. Voss, La Salle’s dean of admission and financial aid, said he felt better about the unexpected decline in SAT scores at his own institution after seeing the national data last week.” Unfortunately, his heightened self-esteem will do nothing to reverse the effects of the 12 years of education that most students receive in public schools.
Though imperfect, the SAT measures verbal and mathematical aptitude. So do the literacy surveys compiled by the Department of Education that display the same downward spiral in grammatical and computational ability.
And now, some of the professors who have to work with students saddled with this inadequate training are starting to speak out more frequently. “I came in on the first wave of spell-check utilities,’ English professor Ben Yagoda writes in The Chronicle of Higher Education. “They lull students and others into a false sense of security, leaving homonyms or near homonyms of the intended word unmarked.”
“Cataloging this kind of mistake can be great sport; I treasure the article about a board-of-education meeting that mentioned the ‘Super Attendant of Schools,’ and the one on drug problems that referred to a ‘heroine attic.’”
Yagoda, who teaches at the University of Delaware, is the author of the forthcoming book, When You Catch an Adjective, Kill It: The Parts of Speech, for Better and/or Worse. “If you stare at such mistakes long enough, some of these actually seem to make sense, as in ‘The storm wrecked [as opposed to wreaked] havoc,’” Yagoda writes. “And some such errors are so inviting that they now outnumber correct usages, at least in my students’ work.”
“I expect to read that something peaked (rather than piqued) the interest, that a person poured (rather than pored) over a book, that an action lead (rather than led) to negative consequences.” Yagoda’s article on “The Seven Deadly Sins of Student Writers” appeared in the September 8th Chronicle Review.
Not too surprisingly he points to public education as the primary reason for the widespread commission of these sins. “The cultural trends that have led to the unmagnificent seven?,” he asks. “The de-emphasis on grammar rules in primary and secondary education has to be a factor, as does the shocking shoddiness with which many students go about their work.”
“That is, if they spent more than a few minutes proofreading their efforts, or thought to consult the dictionary when in doubt about a word, they would catch many or most of their errors.” Along with the lack of training and poor preparation, Yagoda points to the lost art of reading as a reason why students are not prepared to write at college-level.
“Once upon a time, reading was a popular pastime, at least among the portion of the population that went to college,” he concludes. “Until and unless it becomes such again, I'm resigned to making the same corrections on the same mistakes, over and over, until I put away my red pen for good.”
Malcolm A. Kline is the executive director of Accuracy in Academia.
I was a crappy high school student. Had a 3.65 average at graduation from college though.
Simple. Students failing? Lower the standards.
Errors such as those mentioned can be found in any newspaper. Even the professionals make these mistakes, these days. Sometimes I wonder if newspapers even employ editors anymore.
Two possible explanations: grade inflation, or the fact that some august institutions have announced they either don't want or don't take very seriously SAT scores has led students to not take them seriously either.
The first is certainly a bad thing, but there may be two views about the latter, depending on how reliable and useful one believes standardized tests to be.
Unless you happen to be a hugh, series spork weasel.
A=A, unless it's in Cali-forn-ia Public Skoolze, then A=D................
I would have said to the student: "You are EXPECTED to be ACCEPTED, or you'll be EXCEPTED.".............
Academic typso ping! Yew gotta no you're homophones!
If they employed me, they would use homophones correctly!
For all intensive purposes, he's right.
So, if the Dow drops 100 points, that's a "crash."
The uses a RED pen?!?! Doesn't that traumatize his students???
"Academic typso ping! Yew gotta no you're homophones!"
That's the trouble with today's schools. Too darned many homophones pushing their agendas on unsuspecting kids. If we could get the homophones out of schools, things would be a lot better. You won't find any of those filthy homophones in home schools.
it is just not in English that the errors occur. I remeber a newspaper article in early 2002 about a plane taking off from runway 19 at Washington National and flying over the VP's residence after takeoff. (Note: at that time, flights taking off and landing at DCA were required to fly on straight lines and not follow the river as most now do). However, to fly over the VP's residence after taking off from runway 19 would require serious turning because the runway is almost due south (Runway 01 is almost due north)and the runway is south of the residence.
Prole fondness for newspaper words tempts them into some extravagant malapropisms. A writer in the London Sunday Times not long ago testified to hearing that attempts were being made to pervert a strike, and that somewhere a priest had been called in to circumcise a ghost:Readers notify me of the lady with a painful “Ulster” in her mouth; the shrines you can see in Catholic countries in commemoration of “St. Mary Mandolin”; the police at the scene of a crime, who threw “an accordion” round the street; the touching sight of the deceased George V lying in state on a “catapult” . . . the student who was always to be found “embossed” in a book; the pilot who left his aircraft by means of the “ejaculation seat”; . . . the drowning swimmer who was revived by means of “artificial insemination”; and the rainbow which was said by an onlooker to contain “all the colors of the rectum.”— Paul Fussell, Class.
< ;)
"A writer in the London Sunday Times not long ago testified to hearing that attempts were being made to pervert a strike,"
That reminds me of a spelling test I took in 4th grade. The teacher wrote misspelled words on the blackboard, then asked students to spell them correctly, aloud.
One of the words was "pervent." I was the kid who had to correct the spelling. So, being the smartass kid I was, I spelled it aloud...P E R V E R T.
The teacher almost fell down laughing. It was several minutes before the class could continue.
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.