I was eating dinner and heard him say it but wasn't watching so I don't know in what context he said it. It got my attention when he dropped the word agnostic.
Thanks for your report. Given everything, there's no doubt Colmes said he was 'agnostic.' If this blows up into a controversy, look for Colmes to claim he was either joking or agnostic about something other than W's involvement. But I'm becoming more convinced I had it right. Thanks again.