By the way. Maybe in all your disparagement of Giuliani, I missed your recommendation
Who would you like to see as the Republican nominee that you believe will both win and Govern to great success?
And what gives you those beliefs? That they might have said some things you agree with or voted a certain way, wouldn't convince me.
1. Successful executive experience (in either government or private industry).
2. A decent track record when it comes to supporting conservative issues (someone who compromises on certain issues for political reasons is acceptable, but one who does this on 23 out of 25 issues will never be able to credibly stand up and call himself a "conservative."
3. Any executive experience in government must have been in a traditionally conservative jurisdiction.
Item #3 basically disqualifies almost any candidate from the Northeast, Illinois, and the West Coast. That may sound like a silly criterion for someone to have, but I will never trust a candidate who has run a successful campaign in a city or state that would rightly be called a Communist enclave in any other era.