Posted on 07/05/2006 10:37:50 AM PDT by Clint Williams
Georgia’s new sex offender law, ostensibly designed to keep some of society’s worst elements far from where they can cause harm, is already a failure.
The law, which had been scheduled to take effect on July 1, is tied up in court already, a move that likely has law enforcement agencies across the state sighing with relief.
The law has good intentions. It prohibits sex offenders from living within 1,000 feet of a number of places where no one wants them: schools, day care centers, churches, etc. The problem is that once many municipalities began drawing 1,000-foot circles around everything the law enumerates, there were not many places left for sex offenders to live.
The new law prevents sex offenders from living within 1,000 feet of school bus stops. There are more than 2,000 bus stops in Camden County. Once the county finishes drawing 1,000-foot circles around all of them, there probably won't be much real estate, if any, left over in Camden County for sex offenders.
And if there's no room in a mostly rural county like Camden, there won't be any in most of Georgia. This is likely what lawmakers intended when they wrote the law, but it's irresponsible lawmaking at best.
Why?
The law is embroiled in a Constitution-level lawsuit and has had a temporary restraining order placed upon it by a federal judge, blocking its enforcement. The question is whether the law imposes an ex post facto — after the fact — punishment and is therefore unconstitutional is one that will be tied up in court for some time. It's likely the lawmakers knew this before passing the law, but were just hoping to score some points by appearing tough on crime, even though the law can't be enforced and, therefore, has no value.
There are other parts of the legislation that make sense and have the desired effect of clamping down on sex offenders. The law mandates a 25-year prison sentence for rapists and child molesters and requires sexual predators to be monitored by electronic tracking devices.
Perhaps the greatest danger of the new law is that it is so strict that sex offenders will simply stop registering with police departments as required. This registration is vital to helping law enforcement monitor the whereabouts of sex offenders and if sex offenders fail to use it, there is no law enforcement organization in Camden County with the resources to track them all. Other states that have enacted laws similar to Georgia have seen registration rates drop from more than 90 percent to less than 50 percent.
We are all for laws that increase safety for children, but this one needed a little more thought before being enacted.
I saw another story about a boy who was 18 and convicted of 3 different types of sex crimes when he got caught having oral sex with his 16 year old girlfriend in the backseat of a car. He has to register for life and the new law would require his family to move. (he lives with his parents now). They have lived in their house for 32 years or something like that. I guess this is what happens when our elected officials try to fix something without thinking about it. I wonder how many of them ever got lucky in the backseat....I guess none of them.
Wow! And some posters on this thread like Tulane and Paleo Conservative are calling for life imprisonmant, nay execution, for these people.
imprisonment
The politicians are reacting to public hysteria. They need to get a grip. I'm sure there are many more stories like the one you talked about and we haven't heard them. Yet. If the press gets bored, they'll swing the hysteria in the other direction.
According to an article on the blog where I first saw this (I posted the original, not the blog entry), you are correct, Sonny M.
Perhaps they could live in prison rather than out among polite society. What a concept!
Interesting find.
I'm sure glad you made this point. The emotion of this issue makes me wonder if even here the issue has turned people into a hanging mob.
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.