[Dimensio]

b) he broke new ground in judicial overreach in presuming to tell the litigants what science is, rather than just ruling on the case and shutting up.

You are neglecting to mention that the defendants in the case specifically requested a ruling to this effect.

[Almagest]

<< You are neglecting to mention that the defendants in the case specifically requested a ruling to this effect. >>


Thou shalt not use logic when dealing with a lynch mob.

[SamuraiScot]

(He broke new ground in judicial overreach in presuming to tell the litigants what science is, rather than just ruling on the case and shutting up.)

You are neglecting to mention that the defendants in the case specifically requested a ruling to this effect.

I didn't see the motion, but even if they did, it doesn't excuse him taking them up on it, or his Judge Elvis routine. If they'd told him to jump off a building, would he have done that, too? (Maybe so.)

It's just not his job to decide what is science, and considering what he said about the Constitution, I'm not sure he should be talking about the law, either.