I confused Hudson with the case on this thread
That's an understandable and good ruling. They could see a violent crime in progress though the window. In a case in IL, a woman dialed 911 during a rape. The cops got there and waited outside while the cries and screams for help came from inside. The sgt ordered the cops to stay put. The woman was killed in the end. The cops never came to her aid. IMO, the sgt and all involved should get life, no parole.