I read it that she must have described John Doe #3 as having a mustache. Looking at the photo line up she points to someone who looks like mustached #3 but without the mustache.
"looks just like him without the mustache,"
The article is not written very clearly.
http://www.herald-sun.com/durham/4-728827.html
EXCERPT
Also Wednesday, attorney sources said the accuser was only 90 percent sure about her identification of one of three men she said attacked her, and she tripped up over a mustache.
Looking at a photo lineup, the dancer told police the man in question "looks just like him without the mustache," the lawyers said, citing a written investigative report.
But the alleged third rapist had no mustache on the relevant night, if he ever had one, according to attorneys. They said photographs and eyewitnesses would prove their point.
Can't make this stuff up ...
http://www.herald-sun.com/durham/4-728827.html
EXCERPT
In other lacrosse case developments, May 15 is evolving as a potentially pivotal day. That is Nifong's next opportunity to take the name of a third assailant to a grand jury for indictment. Although there's also a grand jury meeting
Monday, Nifong faces a Democratic primary on Tuesday and has said he wouldn't seek and indictment the day before because it would appear to be politically motivated.
May 15 is also the day that a second round of DNA tests is expected back from a private laboratory. It is also the date for the next scheduled preliminary court hearing in the case.
"There will be an interesting confluence of events on the 15th," Nifong said.
When they went in to give DNA samples March 23 wasn't it also reported that they were also going to take pictures at that time for purposes of identification later. Could #3 have had a mustache at that time?