What about two excellent appointments to the Supreme Court?
Way too early to reach any final judgment on Roberts and Alito. IMHO, I do believe Alito will turn out okay. OTOH. We had Ike picking Warren. Nixon choosing Burger. And Reagan nominating O'Conner. Rehnquist, Scalia and Thomas turned out to be solid conservatives. Justices sometimes turn out to be good for America. Sometimes not so good. Sometimes downright bad.