Then gradually, the new theories start to attract new proponents, who have less at stake in the old theories and are willing to consider new ones.
Younger scientists come into the pool, and they are more open to new ideas as the brain-dead old geezers--scientists, administrators, foundations grants directors--retire or die off.
Thomas Kuhn made a persuasive argument for this process, in The Structure of Scientific Revolutions.
"It's par for the course that "established" scientists hate it when new theories are proposed."
ID is old and fossilized. The theory of evolution is the newer claim.
Propose an alternative theory and we'll entertain it.