[Mo1]

These Generals seems to have faulty memories

They seems to forget that many of the Republican Guard put on civilian cloths and meld into the community when our troops rolled into Baghdad

The seems to forget that Saddam didn't think he would be caught .. that he could just hide out for a bit and then take back control of Iraq

Are these generals suggesting that we should have just shot at and rounded up Iraqi's without cause ???

[bert]

I read the whole thread and learned little. hope Kristinn will post a transcript.

I did learn:
Kristinn did good
Somebodies pissed because they didn't get top billing
Chris matthews is a child abuser that makes his kids wear Che T shirts.

[STARWISE]

That's what I was thinking .. and more generally: who on earth can predict with 100% certainty the response, reaction in any war ?? This was Shock & Awe, for pete's sake .... and with NO way to really know what Sadaam or his henchmen had planted or planned. They're dissing W and Rummy because they actually had the nerve to not have crystal balls ...... not meaning in the bad way, but jeesh.