Posted on 02/24/2006 3:41:11 AM PST by saveliberty
By Tony Snow
Feb 24, 2006
WASHINGTON, D.C. -- Washington was wracked last week by a spasm of Know-Nothingism, starring Democratic and Republican members of Congress whose hysterics confirmed the Founders' view that the president, and not the legislature, ought to handle matters of national security.
At issue was a takeover of the British shipping firm P&O by a United Arab Emirates holding company, Dubai Ports World. The transaction, first reported in the British press last Oct. 30, should have been routine. P&O leases cargo terminals at a half-dozen U.S. ports, and pays the longshoremen who load and unload ships.
The ownership change wouldn't have affected anybody on American soil. DPW had agreed to keep the old British management team (comprised of Americans) in charge and would have retained the all-American force of longshoremen at the terminals.
Nevertheless, politicians acted as if the Bush administration, which gave its blessing to the deal, had just exposed America's tender commercial neck to the glinting scimitars of Araby. Republicans behaved worst.
Rep. Tom DeLay denounced the deal as "outrageous." Sen. Bill Frist vowed to put the decision "on hold." Rep. Peter King warned darkly of "very serious al-Qaida connections." And Rep. Sue Myrick, in the most childish letter ever written a president by someone other than a child, wrote: "In regards to selling American ports to the United Arab Emirates, not just NO -- but HELL NO!"
One problem: The United States didn't sell anything. Local port authorities still own the ports, including the cargo terminals rented by firms such as Dubai Ports. The Coast Guard still has exclusive responsibilities for security on the water. The Coast Guard, Customs Service, Border Patrol and local law enforcement still have the duty of maintaining security on the ground. The workforce affected by the change -- fewer than 400 laborers -- by law must have passed federal background checks.
The fulminating honorables would have known this if even one of them had bothered to contact a single person working at or running a port. When asked whether anybody at any port in the land had contacted him with a single security concern since the P&O/DPW deal was announced four months ago, Rep. King replied, "No."
The ignorance didn't stop there. Many critics of the deal also seemed to know nothing of the security cooperation between the United States and the UAE. To reject the deal would be to slap a government that has provided on-the-ground intelligence from the opening salvo of the war on terror. Gen. Tommy Franks notes that the UAE's much-criticized "recognition" of the Taliban actually enabled the country to do first-rate spying. The UAE provided maps and information for the opening invasion of Afghanistan.
The UAE since has put troops on the ground in Afghanistan and Iraq, in active and humanitarian missions. It trains Iraqi forces on its soil. It lets the United States conduct flights through its airspace. It has housed servicemen -- and women -- from the Army, Navy, Marines and Air Force. It maintains the largest U.S. naval facility outside the United States, and Dubai Ports World performs contract service at the port.
It was the first government in the region to comply with the "container security" program launched by the Bush administration, testing every container for nuclear contamination. It now is working to develop technology that would permit the swift and thorough scanning of all containers. Its central bank has become quite active in choking off terror financing. It has rounded up a fair number of al-Qaida operatives and handed them over to the United States, and once -- long ago -- offered to serve as the agent for delivering Osama bin Laden from the Sudan to the Clinton administration.
If the United States were to kill the deal merely because Dubai Ports World was from Dubai, it would send a devastating message to allies in the war on terror: We don't want you, even if you have placed your citizens in harm's way, actively fought the terror cells, and committed blood and treasure to the war itself. This is nothing short of suicidal at a time when the Muslim world is a tinderbox and the United States has been tarred as Public Enemy No. 1.
The good news is that politicians appreciate the absurdity of the position. On Thursday, Karl Rove extended an olive branch, noting that the administration is willing to let Congress study the matter for 45 days, if necessary.
Sen. Chuck Schumer, who got this riot started, quickly declared that he would like that. The White House knows that, in time, facts will annihilate the Know-Nothings, who have swilled a cocktail of ignorance and knee-knocking fear of Muslim Arabs.
The Rove proffer gives both parties a chance to crawl off the shaky limb before they make a tough situation infinitely worse.
Tony Snow is the host of the 'Tony Snow Show' on Fox News Radio.
Copyright © 2006 Tony Snow
The Russian man in the street never hated us. Their elites weren't religious fanatics. They were, as we discovered, old fashioned nationalists. Old fashioned imperialists. And increasingly corrupt ones at that. Their motives were comprehensible and they could be bribed.
Militant Islam is different. They can't be bought. Religious fanatics don't care about money. Look at the furor over the cartoons and tell me how much you trust these people.
The UAE had promised and delivered $100 mil to us for Katrina relief a few weeks ago before this port deal was made. Just heard it on my local radio news. ????!
Very much.
Britain doubtless has plenty of al-Qaeda cells composed of home grown British Islamists. The horse is out of the barn there.
Actually the Russians in the Soviet Union (and all of the other Republics) weren't permitted to speak their mind, which actually creates more similarity to the Middle East today.
Also, did you read the posts from Muslims who disdained the cartoon protest saying in effect, why should I get upset over cartoons when every time I hear a police car, I wet my pants?
1.2 billion people aren't a monolith. And they aren't going to disappear. What do you do?
Excellent!!!!
Well how is it any better if it's an American company? We are not allowed to have authorities look for individuals who have physical characteristics similar to the suspects?
As apparently do the Chinese Communists. I heard Rep. Issa from Long Beach CA say that that port is under Chinese Management. I was not aware of that. I'm not surprised. I don't believe our ports are compromised. Working for a medium-sized corporation, I'm never surprised nowadays when mergers and acquisitions take place that gobble someone or something up. My last job was with a software company that acquired about 10 companies in the six years I was with them. We do it; they do it.
Well Tony will maintain audience along with Rush. Sean has lost a large segment of his audience. These celebrities forget who we elected as President, and it was NOT them! Sean has been very childish in his handling of this controversy.
LLS
I hope so too
Those koolaide drinkers would include General Tommy Franks and Colonel Ollie North, two people he claims are his friends.
We have always had a powerful Southwest based corporate lobby in this country that sell high tech equipment, services, and weaponry to the Muslim world. Bechtel, Enron, Halliburton, etc. And it is embedded in the GOP. It has over the years assured us that Iran and Saudi Arabia were loyal allies because these were their prime customers. We sold them F14s, Phantoms, AWACs, F15s, and just about every high tech item in our arsenal. They had/have been our military-industrial complexes bread and butter customers.
But we know that their perspective was shallow and mistaken. They had intimate business relationships with corrupt elites. They hadn't a clue about the man in the street. It came crashing down when the Shah fell and on 9/11.
So now we have a procession of the same corporate interests and their assorted hangers on in the bureaucracy praising the UAE just as they praised Iran and Saudi Arabia and for the same reasons, and like sinkspur yelling "racism, racism" when their motives are questioned.
Yep, General Tommy Franks and Colonel Ollie North are hangers on. How dare anyone assume that they have a knowledge of the middle east, terrorism and national security greater then yours.
Ok in "devils advocate role",Isn't better that a foreign company have the operations lease, since it is a lot easier to investigate foreign lease holders rather than American lease holders? Did that make sense?
Good morning, sl.
Great read bump!
I listen to Tony Snow (bought XM radio in order to be able to get him) and Rush when I turn on the radio in the afternoon.
I prefer the Snow show, however, and if you can get it it's well worth a listen. Plus he has a daily thread on FR and he posts to us under his own name. Also his producer posts on that thread, too.
He has been doing yeoman's work in getting the facts out about this issue, and has had all sorts of interesting interviews. It is an excellent show!
It's good that we have a few mature pundits around who don't immediately jump on every red herring that comes along.
I think I'm gonna cry. Sniff.
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.