The judge really isn't authorized to determine if anything is truly religious in nature. He should keep that sort of thing to himself and off the bench.
That was pretty much his job as agreed to by the school board.
Not only that, but he had the hubris to decide demarcation criteria for science that philosophers of science have been unable to agree upon. Do those who favor this ACLU victory really want courts determining what is or is "not a scientific theory"?
Cordially,