Not even a toss up for me -- I'll take Rudy in a heartbeat over McCain... MC scares me, Rudy doesn't, at least he would be tough on crime and on terror and I think he could suprise us on the borders, too... unlike John Mc who went all over AZ telling everyone not to vote for Prop 200 last year (passed with a hefty margin, too)....
You obviously don't remember when Rudy refused to enforce the 1996 immigration laws, stating that "New York was open to ALL immigrants" legal or illegal, and that he would not allow authorities to report illegal students in the public schools.