[ozoneliar]

I've said it once; I'l say it again. All JAGs should be given a temporary rank of private, turned over to a line unit or motor T unit going into hostile areas for 6 months before they are allowed to opine, prosecute or judge the conduct of those going "outside the wire", so to speak. This is nonsense.

This person overstepped her bounds. That is no grounds to malign the entire JAG. Most JAG's are hard working, great officers. All JAG's do is advise;that is their job. This JAG was wrong.

[GermanBusiness]

Didn't Tom Cruise immortalize the JAG in "A Few Good Men?"

:-)

When I watch that movie now, I switch the "crime" to the alleged torturing of Al Qaeda prisoners (lapdances, etc).

Then I hear Nicholson say "You want the truth. You can't HANDLE the truth."...and I realize that the movie producers were being cowards by making the crime in the movie a real crime, instead of something only their fellow liberals would agree with.

[Publius6961]

This person overstepped her bounds. That is no grounds to malign the entire JAG. Most JAG's are hard working, great officers. All JAG's do is advise;that is their job. This JAG was wrong.

Of course it's a good reason to malign the entire JAG. Unless they fired her or at least demoted her to a position where she can no longer do something stupid without authorization.
If they have in fact taken steps to deal with her delusional incompetence, my asessment of the entire JAG holds.
And since there was no classified material involved, the demoted sniper (whistleblower) should be reinstated.