Wishful thinking does not equal facts. He's alive. It's him on the tape. Who do you think that was on the Election Eve tape? Rich Little?
So? The AGE of the various portions, wich it was noted by the CIA were edited together, could NOT be confirmed. THAT is why analysts are careful to say "APPARENTLY referring to...[recent event here]"
Binny ranted every day. All his rants were recorded. Even when we were sure he was still alive, some tapes came out where he ranted the entire time about the Soviet invasion and the Gulf war as theough these were recent or current events.
You can believe whatever you want, just as I can.