Its equivalent to someone saying "Geography is all rubbish. What is Planet Earth?"
Well no it is not equivalent to that at all. Thats all you have though, so go with it.
---
Yes it is. Geography is the study of planet earth. Not knowing what the planet earth is is kinda stupid.
Evolutionary science is the sudy of imperfect self replicators. Not knowing what an imperfect self replicator is is kinda stupid.
--
An imperfect self replicator is something that copies itself, but sometimes not with 100% fidelity.
Sounds like a concept Dawkins would come up with. The word 'self' needs taken out.
--
Dawkins hardly came up with idea. It has been known for years. And why does the word "self" need to be taken out?