Posted on 12/25/2005 11:42:40 PM PST by CarrotAndStick
Dallas, April 29: Today's great American hotel owner is more likely to be named Patel and have roots that extend to the Indian state of Gujarat, than to be named Trump and lay claim to premier properties in the New York area.
Immigrants from India, almost all with ties to Gujarat, have become a dominant force in the US hotel industry.
They own about half of the US economy lodging facilities and almost 37 per cent of all hotel properties here, according to the Asian American Hotel Owners Association (AAHOA), based in Atlanta.
This means that if a traveller stops at a Days Inn along Interstate 95 on the way to Washington, a Best Western in rural Montana, or a Holiday Inn Express near Dallas, there is about a 50 per cent chance the hotel is owned by an individual or the family of an immigrant from India.
"The first group found opportunities in the lodgings industry, more by accident than by design," said Hitesh Bhakta, chairman of the AAHOA at the group's convention held in late April at a suburban Dallas hotel.
Indians from Gujarat started to buy into lower-end US hotels in the 1960s and 1970s, when US immigration laws granted residency for new arrivals who invested about $10,000 to run a business. The ethnic group now owns about 20,000 hotels -- about 1 million rooms -- in 50 states.
The first hotels purchased were in run-down areas and typically at the bottom end of the industry, but they did provide the new immigrants with a place to live on the premises. All that was required was for a family to be on call 24 hours a day and be ready to work to keep the hotel operating smoothly.
INVESTING IN VACANCIES
As with many ethnic groups that find a niche in the marketplace, word spread about the opportunities in US hotels.
Most of the immigrants working in the lodgings industry are named Patel, a common surname in Gujarat, said to mean "village chief."
The immigrants also proved themselves to be an extremely low credit risk, making it possible for thousands to invest $10,000 or $20,000 or so as a down payment in a hotel property worth about $100,000 to $120,000.
"The network gave them a business plan," said Bhakta.
"They didn't need consultants. All a potential investor had to do was call up his uncle and ask, 'How much should I pay and is this a good market?'," he said.
In the 1970s, the number of Indians in US lodging expanded greatly. The gasoline crisis in the mid 1970s led to a drop in domestic travel, which increased the investment opportunities in roadside hotels. Indian investors could afford to acquire more properties because they were cheaper.
Immigration laws have changed over the years, making it much more difficult and expensive for new arrivals to gain US residency status by investing in a business, but Indian-Americans had already established a strong presence in the market.
BUYING THE RITZ
The industry group AAHOA was formed in 1989 partly in response to some hotel owners trying to take business away from hotels owned by Indian immigrants by placing an "American owned" sign outside their establishments.
Now, because of the strong presence of Indian immigrants in the industry and tougher rules from hotel franchise operators, the practice of playing on ethnic differences has largely disappeared.
The children of the first generation of hotel owners have taken the path followed by many other second-generation immigrants. Some have shied away from the industry because of the demanding work, while others have gained entree to running more upscale lodging facilities by enrolling in renowned hotel schools at Cornell or New York University or earning advanced degrees in business administration.
"We are turning out a lot of second-generation hotel owners," said Chekitan Dev, a professor of marketing at Cornell's School of Hotel Administration. "They are using their education to take their business to the next level."
One of the many success stories is H.P. Rama, who started with a small investment and took over a 37-room hotel in Pomona, California. He is now the head of JHM Hotels, which runs 32 properties, with 5,000 rooms, in nine states. A founding chairman of AAHOA, he has also served as chairman of the American Hotel & Lodging Association (AHLA).
Rama said he sees an ever-growing presence of Indian Americans at all levels of the US hotel business in the years ahead.
"I have no doubt that the second generation will dominate the lodging industry in this country in all segments of the market," Rama said.
And the white vehicle that the photo is taken over?
Kind of flat for the '50's?
2002 Isuzu Trooper?
I believe Patel means innkeeper.
The article said it means village chief.
>My girlfriend and I stayed at such a motel. As soon as the owner was satisfied that we weren't packing he gave us a room.
The shower had grey-green mold growing in it from floor to ceiling. The shower stall wasn't even tiled!!!!!!!!!!<
Stories like yours are why we have an RV. I know who slept on the sheets last, and I know the shower and toilet are clean!
"As an aside I recall reading about the now-forgotten black motel chains in the South that died out after integration made such special arrangements unecessary."
There were black motel chains in the south in the 50s? What were they? There were black owned motels, but Chains?
Nothing wrong with this at all. These are folks that come to this country and get to work right away.
I do not have any evidence to contradict your opinions. Others here may. You may be right, but I don't know much past this article and the comments herein. As mentioned by you and others here, there must some people on the wrong side of the law. But likewise, there are others who have commented here about their satisfaction with the service they claim to have received. So the charges go both ways, I guess.
Anyway, the bad service you mentioned, do they go beyond the norms of the surrounding area? I mean, it would be hard to imagine a good hotel in a thrashy, remote town. Just asking, since my experience of these motels are limited to not ever having stayed in one.
"Wow, now I'm really sorry we took their land and put them on reservations."
Right! Uncle Tommahawk and all that.
In our small town we have a Patel family who owns a motel. They also have really smart, well-behaved kids.
Upon looking again and blowing up the photo...I think you are correct...however to the very far left is a 57 Ford.
Probably not, but they are beautiful to watch soaring above Rush Lake, or swooping down to grab a gosling off the shore line for lunch. One day last summer I counted 11 beautiful American Eagles riding the air currents above Rush Lake. I rounded a bend in the road behind my home early one morning last summer while out for my walk, and came on one feeding on carrion. He was probably 25 feet from me at one point when he flew off at my approach. Ain't it grand to be alive? This is way off the main topic of Patel Motels, but what the heck.
Let's hear it for the internet! It seems Frederick Winslow "Speedy" Taylor was one of the original triumvirate of gurus of the "Scientific Management" philosophy along with his associates Henry Gantt and Frank and Lillian Gilbreth (best remembered as authors of "Cheaper by the Dozen" apparently originally a treatise on how to efficiently integrate work and family life). Among their many innovations were "motion study", "time study", the "Gantt Chart" (a visual display chart for scheduling), humane management and favorable working conditions, among many other things.
Although it seems no one individual can claim credit for the assembly line, the modern version is largely attributed to both Sears & Roebuck and Henry Ford.
Not many people know that Henry Ford's first claim to fame was as Thomas Alva Edison's chief engineer at his Menlo Park laboratory.
FWIW, there is an event I attend every year. We always stay at the same, Indian-run hotel. Why? The guy is fantastic. He goes well "above and beyond". As long as Indians come here, invest money and provide great service, I'm OK with it.
Same here.. We need more people like them to come to America..
"Not many people know that Henry Ford's first claim to fame was as Thomas Alva Edison's chief engineer at his Menlo Park laboratory."
And Walter P Chrysler started out as a railroad mechnic.
The first thing he had to do as an apprentitice was to make is own tools. His tools are still on display in the Chrysler Building.
Don't quote me on this, but I believe he supported the NAACP financially as well.
I didn't know that about Taylor.
For reasons not quite clear, even to me, I can't think of the guy without thinking of the James Cagney movie 1,2,3...
I understand....my comment was sarcastic.
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.