[VaGunGuy]

If they were in fact taken while under arms, they are not innocent, period. In the case at hand, involving the Australian Taliban, he was taken under arms, not even the defense argues that he wasn't.

[yarddog]

To be clear we are talking about the terrorists in Guantanamo, not every single Iraqi held briefly and questioned then let go.

[Gondring]

If they were in fact taken while under arms, they are not innocent, period.

...implying that if they weren't under arms, they were innocent?