[mvpel]

The Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals has decided, in their infinite(simal) wisdom that the Second Amendment is a "collective right," not individual, and the Supreme Court has declined to hear an appeal.

[Steve_Seattle]

"The Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals has decided, in their infinite(simal) wisdom that the Second Amendment is a "collective right," not individual, and the Supreme Court has declined to hear an appeal."

Making it the ONLY "collective" right in the Bill of Rights. Just goes to show you that liberal dishonesty knows NO LIMITS. A right to abortion - nowhere mentioned in the Constitution, and routinely proscribed by state law for 200 years, is now a "fundamental constitutional right;" the right to bear arms, explicitly mentioned in the Constitution, and assumed by most ordinary Americans to be a basic right, is deemed NOT a constitutional right. BULL****!!!

[elbucko]

The Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals has decided,that the Second Amendment is a "collective right,"...

A "collective right" is an oxymoron and is just about as constitutional as another famous oxymoron, "separate but equal". Both of them are bogus legal concepts.

The 2nd. Amendment is a poor step child to the Left, if not a complete b*st*rd. They would repeal it in a NY minute, if it wasn't part of the sacred "Bill of Rights". They know that once any right is removed from these first ten that the rest will soon fall. That's why the Left tries its best at malignant neglect and abuse to the rights that it doesn't like.

As far as I am concerned, the state of California has no "right" to a militia.