Skip to comments.
CLINTON'S SCOTTISH COURT WARNING
The Daily Record ^
| October 31,2005
Posted on 10/31/2005 4:31:37 AM PST by Plasmaman
FORMER US President Bill Clinton may be forced to appear in court over a medical scandal which claimed the lives of innocent Scots.
Many haemophiliacs were infected with hepatitis C after tainted blood from American prisoners was imported into the UK.
Glasgow firm Thomsons are representing the families of Scots sufferers who died after contracting the disease.
They allege inmates in an Arkansas jail were paid to donate blood despite the authorities knowing they had AIDS and hepatitis.
They are threatening to call the ex-president, who was state governor at the time, to the witness stand.
The infected bloodwasused to make clotting agents for haemophiliacs who require regular blood transfusions Frank Maguire, of Thomsons, said "These allegations are extremely serious and I am now more sure than ever that there should be a full public inquiry into why so many Scots contracted hepatitis C from infected blood products.
Advertisement
"The relatives of my clients who have died want an inquiry to know how their loved ones came to be infected with such a deadly disease, to expose the full facts surrounding their death and bring to light any negligent or discreditable conduct.
"An inquiry would also help to reassure the public that this sort of thing could not happen again.
"If former President Clinton has some information about how this happened in a jail in Arkansas while he was state governor then I'd hope he'd want to give evidence to an inquiry."
The law firm has already taken court action against the Lord Advocate, Colin Boyd, and Health Minister Andy Kerr.
They are calling for a review of their decision not to hold a judicial inquiry into the spate of deaths
TOPICS: Crime/Corruption; Front Page News; News/Current Events; US: Arkansas; United Kingdom
KEYWORDS: blooddonation; bloodtrail; clintonbloodmoney; clintonlegacy; clintonscandals; hepatitis; hepatitisc; scotland; sinkemperor
Navigation: use the links below to view more comments.
first previous 1-20 ... 41-60, 61-80, 81-100, 101-104 next last
To: Plasmaman
61
posted on
10/31/2005 7:28:12 AM PST
by
metesky
(This land was your land, this land is MY land; I bought the rights from a town selectman!)
To: Plasmaman
62
posted on
10/31/2005 7:33:49 AM PST
by
paltz
To: Plasmaman
No fair changin' skins like that!
*chuckle*
Thanks for the article.
Bump.
63
posted on
10/31/2005 7:42:26 AM PST
by
Darksheare
(I'm not suspicious & I hope it's nutritious but I think this sandwich is made of mime.)
To: Sioux-san
64
posted on
10/31/2005 7:44:44 AM PST
by
Robert A Cook PE
(-I contribute to FR monthly, but ABBCNNBCBS supports Hillary's Secular Sexual Socialism every day.)
To: Plasmaman
"If former President Clinton has some information about how this happened in a jail in Arkansas while he was state governor then I'd hope he'd want to give evidence to an inquiry."
There probably was a pay-off in this somewhere. The impeached one doesn't do anything without some money being involved!!
65
posted on
10/31/2005 7:46:21 AM PST
by
LADY J
To: Admin Moderator; Howlin; Jim Robinson
Have these "blood trail" references/sources to Clinton been lost forever?
66
posted on
10/31/2005 7:47:59 AM PST
by
Robert A Cook PE
(-I contribute to FR monthly, but ABBCNNBCBS supports Hillary's Secular Sexual Socialism every day.)
To: Jane Austen
Here's a little story that although reported in Canada (where the prison blood story still captures the public's attention) gives you the scope of the scandal.
The tainted blood scandal is more shameful than Adscam
Globe and Mail
Thurs, April 21, 2005 Page A17
By Andre Picard
In the recent outpouring of pre-election hyperbole, the sponsorship scandal has been described, among other things, as the "worst scandal in Canadian history."
Hold on a second.
The evidence at the Gomery inquiry has been damning and at times disgusting, with sordid tales of millions of dollars wasted on dubious advertising campaigns and allegations of kickbacks, bogus billings, and general sleaziness involving Liberal Party apparatchik and hangers-on. But it's only money, and maybe a few political careers, that have been lost.
Yesterday, a determined but largely overlooked group of activists travelled to Ottawa to remind the press gallery that there is a much bigger and more devastating scandal that is ongoing -- that of tainted blood.
The combination of bureaucratic bungling, lax regulation, short- sighted politicking and penny-pinching, corporate greed and outright misrepresentation has been costly, not only in dollars but in lives. Thousands of Canadians -- 2,000 who contracted HIV-AIDS and another 10,000 or so of those who contracted hepatitis C -- will die because they were exposed to transfusions of contaminated blood and blood products. Many of those deaths were preventable, and would have been prevented had politicians and policy-makers shown leadership and initiative.
And every one of those lives lost should concern us far more than the comparatively trivial sums funnelled to Liberal Party coffers.We should not, of course, downplay or forgive the wrongdoing --criminal and otherwise -- at the heart of the sponsorship scandal. But as we witness the outrage surrounding the testimony at the Gomery inquiry, we should ask ourselves why there was not much more outrage at the revelations of the Krever inquiry.
After all, the failings were sweeping, the malfeasance widespread and the betrayal of public trust profound.
The tainted-blood scandal has long ago fallen from the headlines, so perhaps a reminder of some of the most egregious elements is in order.
Consider the following:
In the two years between the time it became obvious that HIV-AIDS was blood-borne and an effective test was developed, attempts to protect the blood supply were "ineffective and half-hearted," according to Mr.Justice Horace Krever.
The public was lied to about the real risks of infection, told the risk was "one in a million" when it was as high as one in 166 for major surgery;
Blood products that were known to be unsafe were distributed to hemophiliacs to save money; in fact, lists were drawn up of patients who should get the inferior product;
The introduction of a test to detect hepatitis C in blood was delayed for four years. As many as 10,000 people may have been infected in that period;
More than $700-million was wasted on a fractionation plant that was to manufacture blood products. The technology was never up to snuff and thousands of litres of donated blood were wasted.
To make up for the shortfall, highly contaminated blood was purchased from U.S. prisons. (The plant was owned, in part, by the Canada Development Corporation, and Paul Martin was a board member when some of those decisions were made);
The Canadian Blood Committee, a group of senior health officials from the federal and provincial governments, systematically blocked the introduction of safety measures. It also authorized the destruction of all transcripts and recordings of its meetings so it could not be scrutinized;
Thirty-two criminal charges have been laid against four individuals, a pharmaceutical company and the Red Cross. The trials have yet to begin;
About $1.4-billion has been spent to date compensating victims of tainted blood, but a large group of "forgotten victims" (those infected with hepatitis C prior to 1986) has still been left out. The group of "forgotten victims" that surfaced in Ottawa won a small symbolic victory yesterday when Parliament unanimously passed a motion calling for compensation to be extended to everyone -- a mere eight years after Judge Krever recommended they do so.
It has been more than two decades since the tragic events -- principally bureaucratic and political decisions and non-decisions -- at the heart of the tainted- blood scandal began. Yet no one, apart from a few hapless minor officials, has yet paid the price for those misdeeds and those crimes, least of all elected officials.Monique Bégin, the former federal health minister, said it best: "Justice is offended if people at the top of government in bureaucratic structures are not held responsible for their actions, but employees at less senior levels of the hierarchy are. Moreover, public ethics requires that those at the top be accountable."
There is, in the wake of the Gomery inquiry, a perception that the public is irked and wants to "throw the bums out."
Doing so may well be justified. But bear in mind that there are politicians, public servants and contractors with blood on their hands, not just with their fingers in the kitty.
apicard@globeandmail.ca
To: Plasmaman
the RCMP has a full investigation on this crime. It's been active for the last five years. If I recall correctly much of the evidence trail the RCMP wanted to look at was destroyed in a mysterious fire (in Montreal I believe) just as this was coming to light a few years ago.
68
posted on
10/31/2005 7:49:58 AM PST
by
mitchbert
(Facts Are Stubborn Things .)
To: Darksheare
No fair changin' skins like that! Not even on Halloween?
To: Mia T
70
posted on
10/31/2005 7:51:18 AM PST
by
OKSooner
To: Constitutionalist Conservative
Got me there, I forgot what today was.
*chuckle*
Odd, me forgetting something like that.
;-)
71
posted on
10/31/2005 7:51:44 AM PST
by
Darksheare
(I'm not suspicious & I hope it's nutritious but I think this sandwich is made of mime.)
To: mitchbert
yes there was a fire at the Red Cross offices (on the fifth floor, file cabinets in the middle of the building). However, as any socialist government like Canada, the civil service was preoccupied with manufacturing paper.
Plenty of evidence has been found that has led to the Red Cross pleading guilty of a Federal offence (this summer).
Other documents have been found through court challenges for release of information that have now been turned over to the RCMP.
Let's hope that there's enough to lay criminal charges in this instance.
To: George W. Bush
73
posted on
10/31/2005 8:17:46 AM PST
by
txhurl
To: Robert A. Cook, PE
The one or two stories I saw about it up here barely mentioned that Clinton was governor at the time. And that was it.
74
posted on
10/31/2005 8:45:27 AM PST
by
Argh
To: BARBRA; OKSooner; mnehrling; All
- It is stunning that Hollywood would support 2 such obvious thugs and opportunists....
I thought AIDS was one of Hollywood's defining issues....
YOO-HOO BARBRA! Over here!
- CLINTON & THE KILLER BLOOD
-
- THE PROGRESSIVE REVIEW
- UNDERNEWS
- By Sam Smith
- February 18, 1999
-
- In the mid-1980s, as contaminated blood flowed from
- Arkansas inmates to other countries, then-Governor
- W.J. Clinton sat on his hands despite evidence of
- severe mismanagement in his prison system and its
- medical operations. The prison medical program was
- being run by Health Management Associates, which was
- headed by Leonard Dunn, a man who would brag to state
- police of his close ties to Clinton.
-
- Some of the killer blood ended up in Canada where it
- contributed to the deaths of an unknown number of
- blood and plasma recipients. An estimated 2,000
- Canadian recipients of blood and related products got
- the AIDS virus between 1980 and 1985. At least 60,000
- Canadians were infected with the hepatitis C virus
- between 1980 and 1990. Arkansas was one of the few
- sources of bad blood during this period.
-
- The Royal Canadian Mounted Police has a staff of 24
- working on the case. So far, investigators have
- interviewed about 600 people including in the U.S.,
- Germany and the Netherlands. According to the Ottawa
- Citizen, the team has amassed more than 30,000
- documents.
-
- Other Arkansas plasma was sent to Switzerland, Spain,
- Japan, and Italy. In a case with strong echoes of the
- Arkansas scandal, a former premier of France and two
- of his cabinet colleagues are currently on trial
- stemming from the wrongful handling of blood
- supplies. Some of the blood in the French controversy
- may have come from Arkansas.
-
- A 1992 Newsday report on the French scandal noted
- that three persons had been convicted for their role
- in distributing blood they knew was contaminated:
- "Throughout the 1980s and later, blood was taken from
- prison donors for use in blood banks despite a series
- of directives warning against such a practice.
- According to the report, donations from prisoners
- accounted for 25 percent of all the contaminated
- blood products in France. Blood from prisons was 69
- times more contaminated that that of the general
- population of donors."
-
- The Arkansas blood program was also grossly
- mishandled by the Food and Drug Administration. And
- the scandal provides yet another insight into how the
- American media misled the public about Clinton during
- the 1992 campaign. The media ignored a major Clinton
- scandal despite, for example, 80 articles about it in
- the Arkansas Democrat in just one four-month period
- of the mid-80s.
-
- Here's how Canada's Krever Commissioner report
- describes the beginnings of the problem:
-
- "During 1981-2, the number of AIDS cases in the
- United States reported to the Centers for Disease
- Control in Atlanta grew at an alarming rate. The vast
- majority of the reported cases were of homosexual men
- and intravenous drug abusers. During 1982, cases of
- AIDS transmitted through the use of blood and blood
- products began to be reported.
- The U.S. blood and plasma centers regularly collected
- from two groups of persons who were at high risk of
- contracting AIDS: homosexual men and prison inmates.
- Plasma was collected at centers, licensed by the Food
- and Drug Administration, in prisons in Arkansas,
- Florida, Louisiana, and Mississippi. By way of
- contrast, because of the high prevalence of hepatitis
- B in prisons, the Canadian Red Cross Society had
- stopped collecting donations from prison inmates in
- 1971."
-
- Suzi Parker, writing in the Arkansas Times, described
- the scene: "At the Cummins Unit of the Arkansas penal
- system during the 1980s, while President Clinton was
- still governor, inmates would regularly cross the
- prison hospital's threshold to give blood, lured by
- the prospect of receiving $7 a pint. The ritual was
- creepy to behold: Platoons of prisoners lying supine
- on rows of cots, waiting for the needle-wielding
- prisoner orderly to puncture a vein and watch the
- clear bags fill with blood. Administrators than sold
- the blood to brokers, who in turned shipped it to
- other sates and to Japan, Italy, Spain and Canada.
- Despite repeated warnings from the Food and Drug
- Administration, Arkansas kept its prison plasma
- program running until 1994 when it became the very
- last state to cease selling its prisoners' plasma.
-
- Mike Galster, a medical practitioner whose
- fictionalized account dramatically raised interest in
- the blood scandal, recalls that at the Pine Bluff
- unit's hospital they also took blood from prisoners.
- When he raised questions about the wisdom of bleeding
- sick people, he was told that even the ill had the
- right to sell their blood.
-
- Here is a time-line of this as yet too known Arkansas
- horror story:
-
- 1981
-
- The Arkansas Board of Corrections puts A.L. "Art"
- Lockhart in charge of the state's troubled prisons.
- An Arkansas Gazette front page feature on Lockhart
- begins by noting that he is "dogged by a public
- reputation as a man who runs roughshod over the
- constitutionally guaranteed rights and welfare of
- inmates. 'I don't why,' he said in an interview with
- the Gazette. 'I don't deserve it.'"
-
- The state's prisons are already a mess. Ten years
- earlier Lockhart had taken over the notorious Cummins
- facility which, according to a member of the
- corrections board, was "still controlled by inmate
- trusties with guns. The inmates called the shots. A
- lot of experts said there was no way to take the guns
- away from them without a riot. But Art did it without
- spilling any blood."
-
- But the Gazette also notes: "The prison system, and
- Cummins, in particular, still is in the transition
- from an institution controlled by the inmates to one
- controlled by guards. On many nights at Cummins,
- there are as few as half a dozen guards to watch
- about 1,650 inmates."
-
- Two years earlier, a prison monitor hired under a
- federal court order, released a report saying there
- was "clear and convincing evidence" that Lockhart and
- other employees beat and kicked inmates needlessly
- after an attempted escape from Cummins. Another
- prison mediator charged that the abuse of inmates had
- increased under Lockhart and that he had obstructed
- efforts at prison reform.
-
- Health Management Associates wins a contract to
- provide health services to state inmates, including
- running a blood plasma donor program.
-
- The Centers for Disease Control and World Health
- Organization establish that AIDS is a blood-borne
- disease. CDC recommends testing and sterilization of
- donor blood. The warning is widely ignored and, as a
- result, according to WHO, some one million people
- become infected. Twenty-two countries will eventually
- have to pay compensation as a result.
-
- FDA asks US companies not to buy prison plasma since,
- due to unsafe sexual and drug practices by many
- inmates, the blood has a high risk of carrying the
- AIDS virus.
-
- JUNE 1983
-
- HMA tells FDA that 38 units of plasma from four
- inmates of the Grady prison should not have been
- collected because the prisoners had once tested
- positive for hepatitis B despite a test at the time
- of collection being negative. HMA sees the hazard as
- slight and thinks there is no need to recall the
- plasma. The Canadian Krever Commission will later
- report that "by 1983, however, an association had
- been identified between hepatitis B and AIDS; most
- persons with AIDS had also been infected with
- hepatitis B. There was a greater than average risk
- that the 38 units of plasma from the four inmates
- could transmit AIDS. Four of the units ended up in
- Canada, the others were sold to corporations in
- Switzerland, Spain, Japan, and Italy."
-
- AUGUST 1983
-
- HMA decides to withdraw the 38 units from circulation
- and FDA concurs. This is the first time that
- Connaught, the Canadian blood firm, has heard of any
- problems. The shipping papers had only shown that the
- blood came from "ADC Plasma Center, Grady, Arkansas."
-
- By this time, however, the blood is already in
- circulation and only 417 of 2409 vials are retrieved.
-
- The same month HMA tells the FDA of a fifth inmate
- with similar problems. He had given 34 units in less
- than a year.
-
- SEPTEMBER 1983
-
- Connaught reviews its approvals for receipt of plasma
- from US centers and finds that twelve have never been
- properly approved. One is the prison center in Grady,
- Arkansas. Other questionable blood has come from four
- prisons in Louisiana. Canadian Red Cross nullifies
- its contract for the blood the same day it finds this
- out.
-
- FEBRUARY 1984
-
- FDA suspends plasma production at the Grady facility
- where an average of 550-600 inmates have been giving
- blood since 1967. UPI regional wire reports that FDA
- finds overbleeding of inmate donors, disqualified
- donors, lack of documentation of testing, and
- inadequate storage. It also notes inaccurate and
- incomplete storage, instances of intentional and
- willful disregard for proposed standards, alteration
- of records and files to conceal violations, as well
- as inadequate training and ineffective supervision of
- the plasma center staff. Within months, however, HMA
- successfully applies for a new license after blaming
- the problems on a corrupt clerk.
-
- 1985
-
- A UPI story recounts how the largest inmate donor
- program in the country -- in the Louisiana state
- prison -- is coming under increased federal scrutiny
- because of what is dubbed the "AIDS scare." Says the
- state's secretary of corrections: "We have no
- intention of shutting it down. It would have the same
- impact as a major industry shutting down in a small
- town: economic chaos." The president of a plasma
- company is quoted as saying, "There is no scientific
- evidence that prisoner plasma is worse than street
- plasma." The programs had, in fact, been shut down
- for six months but were reinstated after the prison
- discovered foreign markets to replace a dwindling US
- demand. Says the plasma company president, "I'd say
- 70 to 80 percent is going overseas. There's a good
- market for it over there, and they don't ask where it
- came from."
-
- FDA finally requires testing of donor blood. Tainted
- blood distribution will continue inside the US until
- 1986. Thereafter, contaminated blood stocks will
- still be shipped from US companies to other
- countries.
-
- Prosecuting attorney Wayne Matthews, after a two
- month state police probe, finds no evidence of drug
- trafficking in the Arkansas prison system. The
- allegation is that HMA employees are diverting drugs
- from the department's pharmacy and selling them to
- inmates, and that prisoners who 'knew too much' about
- drug trafficking were killed or allowed to die.
- "There's just absolutely no evidence whatsoever,"
- says Matthews.