[chgomac]

"we have to pre-judge to some extent"

Sure we do....but GWB didn't chose her in a vaccuum! I tend to give him some credit for putting some thought into this choice. Why? Because he has a track record of choosing well. This is an important matter....a lifetime appointment.....is it OK if we gather the facts about her, look at them with some perspective and then decide?

[handy]

Sure we do....but GWB didn't chose her in a vaccuum! I tend to give him some credit for putting some thought into this choice. Why? Because he has a track record of choosing well. This is an important matter....a lifetime appointment.....is it OK if we gather the facts about her, look at them with some perspective and then decide?

Of course it's OK to gather facts. So far I'm underwhelmed. I hope she is a female Thomas and serves 50 years. I hope I eat crow for the rest of my days. So far I'm still disappointed when Luttig was available. With respect to Bush's "track record of choosing well.deciding well" there are few decisions I've not been a fan of. I hope he is right and I'm wrong on this one.

[ohioWfan]

is it OK if we gather the facts about her, look at them with some perspective and then decide?

NO!! We have to have a hissy fit RIGHT NOW!!