Haha - I guess I didn't word my question clearly. What I meant to ask was what sort of things did the Creationists object to in a math class?
Understanding Evolution. Univ. of California.
Statement on the Teaching of Evolution. By the American Astronomical Society.
Some extra info on that last link: AAS denounces "intelligent design".
Another service of Darwin Central, the conspiracy that cares.
Mostly, they would want to discuss religion or just comment about their rebirth os something equally off topic. There were those (not necessarily creationists) who objected to calling imaginary numbers "numbers." (The anti-set theory guys hadn't arrived yet.)