In an officer, I think I prefer initiative, bravery, and 'conspicuous gallantry above and beyond the call of duty' to someone who just simply follows his orders.
Exactly - it is what makes our military *unique* on this planet - this is the only one that accentuates individuality, thinking, flexibility and problem solving instead of only order following.
The fact that these two gentlemen aren't on the receiving end of Courts Martial or Article 15 proceeding shows that they got off lightly. Most servicemembers guilty of dereliction of duty, which this clearly was even though they were helping people, would be in the kennel instead of watching one. It is usually easier to ask for forgiveness than permission (that is one of my mottos), but these LT's may have jeopardized other lives by NOT following orders given to them by their commanders, who undoubtedly have more information of their missions and objectives.
Unless that officer jeopardized your mission by his disobedience.