Vetustodermis planus
Posted on 08/18/2005 12:55:47 PM PDT by LibWhacker
A strange 525 million-year-old fossil creature is baffling scientists because it does not fit neatly into any existing animal groups.
The animal, from the early Cambrian Period, might have belonged to a now extinct mollusc-like phylum, academics from America and China say.
Other researchers have suggested the creature could represent an early annelid or arthropod.
Details are published in Proceedings of the Royal Society B.
The 5-10cm-long (2-4 inch) fossil, from Anning in China, had a flattened body and horizontal fins which, researchers think, could have been used to support it as it moved along the sea floor. It also had well developed senses, including a pair of eyes on stalks.
The trouble is the animal, named Vetustodermis planus, did not possess a set of features, or characters, which placed it clearly within any known group.
When it was first described in 1979, Vetustodermis was included in the annelid category. Later researchers argued against this classification, saying it was, in fact, either an arthropod or a mollusc.
Flat foot
According to the latest study, the weird creature seems closest to molluscs, primarily because it had a snail or slug-like flat foot. However, the researchers say, it does not sit happily in this group.
"Phyla are defined by an organism having a set of features called characters, and currently there are no animals that we know of which contain the set of characters that Vetustodermis has," co-author David Bottjer, of the University of Southern California, US, told the BBC News website.
"The phylum with which it shares the most characters is the Mollusca, but squeezing Vetustodermis into the mollusca is a somewhat messy job."
Since Vetustodermis requires some "pushing and pulling" to force it into any known phylum, Professor Bottjer and his colleagues are tempted to speculate it belonged to a different group entirely; one which flourished and faded within the Cambrian.
"We have always been intrigued by the many molluscan features of these fossils, but in the great menagerie of organisms that have inhabited Earth through life's long history, we may come to conclude that Vetustodermis indeed represents a new phylum," he said.
Jonathan Todd, a palaeontologist from the Natural History Museum, London, UK, is also mystified by the baffling animal.
"It is an intriguing beast," he told the BBC News website. "It is another strange thing from the Cambrian. It doesn't look much like an arthropod and I don't find its molluscan affinities particularly convincing."
Evolutionary tree
However, Dr Todd is reluctant to create a whole new phylum to accommodate Vetustodermis; that, he thinks, would be premature.
"Some scientists have thought that there were so many distinct phyla in the Cambrian," he said. "They came to that conclusion because they were not thinking in the phylogenetic sense, they were thinking 'hey, that is a unique set of features - it must be a distinct phylum'."
So rather than creating new phyla every time something doesn't fit an existing one, the really interesting exercise, Dr Todd thinks, is to establish just how Vetustodermis slotted into the greater evolutionary tree.
If, indeed, it did belong to a different phylum, how did that group connect to the molluscs, annelids and arthropods?
"We don't really know the phylo-genetic relationships between the extant phyla," he said. "Molecular genetics has only gone so far. But recent phyla have got to connect somehow. These fossils really offer the opportunity to tie together recent phyla."
It the ancestor of all Scientologists.
You see, they believe TMJ is caused by repressed racial memories of being clams way back when.
www.xenu.com
Perhaps it's a dorkfish?
It's all Bush's fault. :)
I think Monica caught this from Bill.
I think it's a proto-democrat!
Have they considered that this may be a JUVENILE form of a mollusk or other phylum?...........
cambrian ping
Can't be! I distinctly see a brain..........
"Perhaps it's a dorkfish?"
Were there any corndog wrappers around it?
Here's another fossil that defies grouping.........
It's a Regulan Blood Worm.
Not unusual, but most interesting. Some early life forms God was experimenting with which led to evolutionary dead ends.
A number of weird invertebrate fossils have previously been recovered from the Burgess Shale deposits in North America, which defied modern classification.
But I agree. It definitely has Democrat features.
Reminds me of a girl I used to date...
Odd little critter. Okay, I'm cranking up the ping machine ...
"Here's another fossil that defies grouping........."
Or GROPING for that matter!
AAAAACKKKK!!!..........
|
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.