Though the landfill witness sounded creditable, this part of his story just doesn't jive.
Also, while Joran and his buddies might have been on the prowl for new conquests at C & C, I seriously doubt that it was commit homicides. More likely a roll in the hay -- or sand, since it's Aruba.
No more then three guys pretending to be a cab and going back to the hotel, or slipping a date rape drug into drinks, or any of the other things that might have happened in the last 9 weeks.
I thin it's unconscionable that IF this witness actally witnessed all he;s claimed that he didn't immediately go running to the Holiday Inn to inform Beth and Jug, since everyone on that island knew where to find the Halloway's and twitty's.
I think they just wanted to have sex with a girl from the US and did not intend to kill her. But I could be wrong. It was incredibly dumb if that was their intent, to kill. Did they really think that could be done with no fuss.
"Though the landfill witness sounded creditable, this part of his story just doesn't jive."
Nonsense. It is very believable.....he said it happened at 4:30-5:30.....just before to just after quitting time when the dump would be empty of people out in the back 40.....but still accessible....esp to people with "standing"
Well I think it's a pretty bizarre tale..
A huge how many people.. 4 or 5 from the sounds of it.. going out in broad daylight to dispose of the body in a rather obvious place.. and just cover it up with a swimming pool? Kinda weird..
Also I'm having problems with the trash bag.. that musta been one big Hefty bag.. Don't you think the group would have freaked if the body came 1/2 out of the bag?
"Doesn't anyone except Greta think it's just a tad surealistic for a crowd of people to be disposing of a body in broad daylight while other folks are nearby and conveivably watching?
Though the landfill witness sounded creditable, this part of his story just doesn't jive."
I thought a lot of the landfill's guy's story was hinky.
Three vehicles, a women, 3 or 4 men. It was either Natalee or a coconut tree. And why in the world didn't he go check it out after the people left. It sounded like he waited a day or two to call the police.
"Also, while Joran and his buddies might have been on the prowl for new conquests at C & C, I seriously doubt that it was to commit homicides. More likely a roll in the hay -- or sand, since it's Aruba."
Yep! It also sounded like the girl was interested in Joran. How else would she noticed what door Joran came in. Supposedly, he didn't use the one most customers used. She must have spotted him as soon as he came into the club. Also, the girl said he went to the bar and ordered 151 drinks. If he went to the bar to order, I wonder how she heard what drinks he ordered. Usually, you can't hear the orders given to the bartender from a table, especially where there is dancing and music in the background.
After hearing the landfill story, I see why Dave Holloway had doubts about the story, even though he and his group were searching the landfill with the rest of the volunteers.