NO - They need to be killed.
There's too many to kill. Active terrorists need to be killed, the rest of the Muslims, who by inaction allow the crimes to be committed, need to be shamed.
To be effective, Muslims must be shamed in a way that that makes sense to them. For Muslims, being told they act like unwelcome company is shameful. In Muslim countries visiting and being "company" in someone's home is a big deal. A much bigger deal than it is here -- with complicated, counterintuitive rules.
We have to work within a mental framework they understand. A transgression has to be a "transgression" for them to see it. (It's why liberal PC worked so well on our culture until we figured it out -- but that's another issue) Being "rude" in a home is unforgivable for Muslims... Killing someone isn't.
They have more reasons why it's OK to murder someone than they have reasons why it's OK to get dirt on the rugs or to show the bottom of your shoes, or to not be gracious to a guest. When we're dealing with the enemy, we need to understand what they can "get."