[John Valentine]

Disappeared from her room between 5 and 6 AM while the ship was in port, by the way. Speculation by some on this thread that Amy fell off the ship seems way silly.

[fatnotlazy]

Disappeared from her room between 5 and 6 AM while the ship was in port, by the way. Speculation by some on this thread that Amy fell off the ship seems way silly.

***

Silly? Not necessarily. Wee hours of the morning, maybe too much to drink...not a lot of people around. It could happen.

[smew]

I would like to clarify the story. I am from Aruba, and it is my understanding that three waiter asked her to go to the same club where Natalee was last seen, but she refused.
She dissapeared from the ship between 5-6 am but it was no longer in Aruba. It was enroute to Curacao a nearby Island.
That is where someone supossidly saw her last in a brothel. Don't know if that part is true, but her parents confirmed she did not leave the ship with the three waiters who were not from Aruba, they were workers on a cruise ship out of Florida.