Rip..your comment about all 3 boys having their way with Natalee is what I had suspected from the beginning.
After they gang banged her, they may have realized she could report them to LE and that's when Natalee met her fate. "A bad thing happened to Natalee"...Yes..them.
Yep. The difference between this evening's fun and most others for them was that she wasn't willing and she could ID them. Maybe the stuff that looked like blood was a beverage that they had doctored up for her, but she wouldn't drink it, and she hadn't gotten into the car willingly either and maybe she said she was going to go to authorities about that as well.
I think they got her in the car by the two brothers driving real slow and Snoot grabbed Natalee and tossed her in. At first she might have thought she was still ok, because she recognized them and they probably told her that they were going to give her a lift to the hotel. Once she realized that wasn't happening all heck probably broke loose.