Posted on 06/09/2005 1:35:23 PM PDT by kristinn
June 3, 2005
Mr. Brad C. Deutsch
Assistant General Counsel
Federal Election Commission
999 E Street, N.W.
Washington, DC 20463
Re: Draft Notice of Proposed Rulemaking on Internet Communications
Dear Mr. Deutsch:
Please accept these comments on the proposed rules for FEC regulations of Internet Communications (11 CFR Parts 100, 110 and 114) pursuant to Notice 2005-10.
Please note that we are requesting to give public testimony at the hearing scheduled June 28-29, 2005.
FreeRepublic.com is an internet based electronic bulletin board owned by Free Republic, LLC, in Fresno, California. James C. Robinson of Fresno is the principal owner of Free Republic, LLC
FreeRepublic.com was founded in 1996 as a forum to discuss and expose the crimes of the Clinton administration and to further conservatism.
FreeRepublic.com’s mission statement is: “Free Republic is the premier online gathering place for independent, grass-roots conservatism on the web. We're working to roll back decades of governmental largesse, to root out political fraud and corruption, and to champion causes which further conservatism in America. And we always have fun doing it. Hoo-yah!”
Since it’s founding, FreeRepublic.com has been a pioneer in online political expression in America. It is one of the most popular and influential sites on the Web. Its Alexa.com rating is the 1366th most popular Website. In contrast, the liberal blog DailyKos.com is ranked 5386th and the liberal forum DemocraticUndeground.com is ranked 4,108th.
The content on FreeRepublic.com consists of postings by registered account holders (over 200,000) and Mr. Robinson. The postings can be news articles, commentaries, personal observations, and calls to First Amendment activities such as demonstrations and e-mails or phone calls. Members post from all over the United States and the world.
There are also repostings of campaign literature, links to 501c3 and 501c4 organizations, 527s and an occasional campaign Website. Those links are provided without cost and at the discretion of Mr. Robinson.
Links to such organizations are done so free of charge. FreeRepublic.com has no paid advertising. Its budget consists solely of donations by members and lurkers. There are no membership fees or dues. The postings (except private messages between members) at FreeRepublic.com are open to all to read without membership. Anyone with access to a computer and a modem can read FreeRepublic.com.
FreeRepublic.com is not a blog. It was founded several years before Blogs came into existence.
FreeRepublic.com has been called a modern day Liberty Tree, where concerned citizens use modern technology to exercise their First Amendment rights. FreeRepublic.com has been credited with helping to cause the impeachment of President Clinton. The phrase “broken glass Republican” was coined by a Freeper on FreeRepublic.com during the 2000 election. FreeRepublic.com was also instrumental in exposing the fake Bush National Guard documents that were used by CBS News in a story last fall that tried to influence the 2004 presidential election.
FreeRepublic.com members also report news. For example, the explosion of the Columbia space shuttle was first reported on FreeRepublic.com.
The Internet has proven to be an invaluable tool for average Americans to get their voices heard by those in power. FreeRepublic.com is read by leaders in all branches of the federal government and political parties. It is used as show prep for talk radio and as a research tool for reporters and authors.
Given that the First Amendment guarantees freedom of speech and petitioning of the government, citizen Websites like FreeRepublic.com should be exempt from FEC regulation. If the FEC grants exemptions for public communications to Blogs, electronic bulletin boards like FreeRepublic.com should be given the same exemptions.
Members who post comments and articles, etc. on FreeRepublic.com are anonymous unless the poster identifies themselves. This anonymity is a central point to freedom of expression on the Internet. Just as whistleblowers like Deep Throat hide in anonymity to protect themselves from retribution from those in power in the government, so do posters at FreeRepublic.com.
Any effort by the government to force the disclosure of posters’ identities to meet some draconian federal regulation would have a chilling effect on free speech, especially if that speech involved advocating for or against political candidates.
FreeRepublic.com has an internal private message system similar to e-mail that can be used to communicate privately between members. Such a system should not be regulated by the FEC, as it is a free service.
The free dissemination and reposting of campaign material on the Internet should be exempt, including links to campaign and party Websites should be exempt from regulation.
Mr. Robinson, and the posters at FreeRepublic.com are very concerned that after this first step by the government to rein in free speech on the Internet, more attempts will follow. We strongly urge the commission to respect the First Amendment rights of Americans.
Very truly yours,
Kristinn Taylor
Spokesman, FreeRepublic.com
Penumbra?
If given the chance to supplement your material or testify, please note FR is self-regulating and self-correcting as to bad language, personal attacks, vitriolic racism, pornography, copyright abuse or misrepresentation of facts, news, other's statements, etc.
Jim Robinson and helpers have done a good job of making FR a place to express conservative ideas and opinions. We don't need strict oversight by the FEC in what happens here. Election "reform" shouldn't be the end of free speech.
To enforce the regulations, they'll have to be able to identify those who they think broke them.
Good job, clear and to the point!
I'm sorry, I do not understand the implication of your first statement, perhaps you can clarify. This would seem to be a comment reserved for those who do regularly use personal attacks, racism, porn, or copyright abuse, etc.
As to your second statement, I wholeheartedly agree.
Very well expressed!
Good job guys. Good luck at the hearings.
Good letter. Very clear. Thanks, Kristinn and Jim!
Grate job! Thank you, Kristinn!!
Excellent. I would expect nothing less from you.
< snip > Free Republic is one of 22 groups and individuals that requested to testify at the FEC's public hearings June 28-29, 2005. < snip >
Outstanding kristinn, as usual.
Thank you! That was a well-done bit of work.
I hope the DUmmyland crowd reads this. :)
Good job, kristinn.
Not.
This isn't a "Tech" ping, but if could definately affect us!
Thanks for the ping! Great stuff here.
ping
Thanks, Jim. Should be an interesting hearing later this month.
BTTT
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.