|
Printer friendly version |
Three Weeks in a Progressive Swamp
Through the first three weeks of May, the Rockridge Institute, a California-based politically progressive think tank, partnered with a coalition of religious organizations to host an online conference on Values and Building a Movement. After going to http://www.rockridgeinstitute.org, signing on and getting my password, this conservative Calvinist Presbyterian elder waded into a post-modern religious and political slough. Sometimes I felt like Dorothy in the Wizard of Oz, being spun around in a cultural tornado that left me wondering, I dont think were in Kansas anymore, Toto! North Florida, where I grew up, is a long way from the plains of Kansas, so I have a hard time framing reality in tornado terminology. But I know swamps. As a youngster, I learned to appreciate swamps for their diversity in fauna and flora. Their beauty, however, belies dangers lurking out of sight; beneath the skiff, in the trees and along the banks. Alligators and snapping turtles large enough to cleave off a leg, water moccasins dropping from tree branches and panthers in the bush are some of the dangers hidden amid the beauty. The slough of post-modern religious and political progressivism contains its own perils. Ostensibly, this was a religious conference coordinated by the Buddhist Peace Fellowship, Christian Alliance for Progress, Muslim Peace Fellowship and Tikkum, a Jewish group. Avowed atheists and pagans also participated. The purpose was to reframe the progressive agenda to make it more acceptable to the electorate. After a few days discussing the nature of God and whether what one believes about Him (or Her) should influence public policy, I concluded that religious progressives passionately believe almost anything about not much and not much about almost anything. Progressives frame reality outside the context of a master narrative with each individuals truth determined by gender, sexual-orientation, race and class. My contentions that the Bible is the authoritative Word of God, Jesus Christ the only way to salvation, and that same sex marriage is sinful got me dubbed a Konservative Khristian. One correspondent suggested I might be a freeper who reports to the Karl Rove Gang. (A freeper is someone who reads The Free Republic. Sorry, Im a trender who reads Motor Trend.) Most of the conferees busied themselves with framing or reframing the progressive political agenda. Their departure point is that Konservative Khristians from the religious right hijacked the body politic. Progressive political articles of faith are that President Bush stole the elections of 2000 and 2004 and also lied about weapons of mass destruction to justify invading Iraq so defense contractors and Halliburton could make big bucks destroying then rebuilding the nation while American oil companies appropriated Iraqi petroleum. Their immediate objective is to compel the House Judiciary Committee to investigate the Downing Street Memorandum, a document published last month in European papers that purports to be the July 2002 smoking gun revealing Bushs perfidy in manipulating intelligence to support an invasion of Iraq. The ultimate objective is for a radicalized Democratic Party to regain both houses of Congress and the presidency by 2008
hopefully earlier with the impeachment of Bush. Dorothy, do they have swamps in Kansas? Otherwise, the progressive agenda is familiar: legalize gay marriage, retain unimpeded access to abortion, hike taxes to expand government social, medical and welfare programs and to save social security. Progresso-babble concerning radio-active particles in the atmosphere, global warming, along with contentions that the Bush administration engineered 9/11 crept into the frame. Aware that most Americans reject most if not all their agenda, how they frame their arguments is vital. One correspondent warned, In terms of political discourse, gay rights and abortion are clearly wedge issues purposely positioned by political conservatives to keep us off the bread and butter issues. But does that mean that we should abandon the dialogue concerning moral fairness and diversity? Translate that, frame to fool so we can win. Beware the gators and snapping turtles in the progressive slough. The progressive lefts immediate goal is to discredit and (they hope) impeach the President by contending he manufactured intelligence to support invading Iraq. One correspondent, noting that impeachment is unlikely, recommended focus on War Crimes (sic) as the vehicle for bringing Bush & Co. to justice. Constant carping that Bush lied joined to contentions that American soldiers are committing war crimes in Abu Ghraib and the Guantanamo Gulag will result neither in impeachment nor increased voter support for the progressive agenda. It may, however, encourage terrorists to step up their attacks hopeful that help is on the way in the guise of a new administration. Meanwhile, progressive protestations that we are doing this to support the troops are disingenuous and dangerous. Make no mistake, progressives want to discredit the administration and regain political power. What they envision is unfathomable to most Americans. ____________________________________________________________________________ Dr. Earl H. Tilford is a professor of history at Grove City College and he is a fellow with The Foundation for the Defense of Democracies. He enjoyed an extensive military career and after retiring from the U.S. Air Force, served as an associate professor of history at Troy State University in Montgomery and professor of military history at the U.S. Air Force Air Command and Staff College. In 1993 he became director of research at the U.S. Army's Strategic Studies Institute in Carlisle, Pa., where he worked on a project that looked at possible future terrorist threats. He has authored three books on the Vietnam War and co-edited a book on Operation Desert Storm. He has lectured throughout the U.S. and abroad on the Vietnam War and, more recently, the future of armed conflict. Contact him at ehtilford@gcc.edu.
Join - Join the Vision & Values Concise mail list if you would like some of our faculty's best opinion editorials sent to you on a weekly basis. More faculty opinions
Support Grove City College with a gift. Thank you!
Barron's lists Grove City College as one of the 65 Most Competitive colleges in the nation. U.S. News & World Report ranks Grove City as # 1 Best Value and # 5 Best College in its category. With an enrollment of 2,300 students and located on a beautiful campus, Grove City College advocates the free market economic system and accepts no federal funding. Founded in 1876, Grove City College is a private Christian college teaching the liberal arts, sciences and ABET-accredited engineering. Tuition is less than half of the national average for private colleges. Activities include 20 varsity sports teams, club and intramural sports, a large music program and 130 student organizations. Grove City is located 60 miles north of Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania. -30- (Feedback? Contact news@gcc.edu) |