[Hillary's Lovely Legs]

I'd also bet he is a Christian ... . His parents have every right to be very proud of him.

What if he's Jewish? Should his parents not be proud if him?

[t_skoz]

Good point, HLL.

I was just going to point out that the kid looks an awful lot like the Jewish kids in my old neighborhood. A lot of Jewish families homeschool their kids!

[nmh]

"What if he's Jewish? Should his parents not be proud if him?"

It's typically Christians that homeschool. He name sure doesn't sound very Jewish.

What if he is Jewish?

Do you think his parents shouldn't be proud of him?

It seems to me that you are alittle defensive.

[nonsporting]

What if he's Jewish? Should his parents not be proud if him?

Logical fallacy alert!

(P -> Q) does not imply (~P -> ~Q)

(P -> Q) | (~P -> Q) (theorm 22 in my Logic text, affectionately referred to by Ms. Clark, the instructor, as "damned if you, damned if you don't." In this case "blessed if you are a Chrisian, blessed if you are not (i.e. Jewish)."

Or course in the original post P and Q are not related.