Posted on 05/17/2005 12:34:50 PM PDT by FoxPro
But Leviticus 18:22 is not important?
Your historical splitting of Karaite hairs may be true, but just remember...
We are all god's children !
Oznaim L'Torah on our parsha, 22:18. Why does Hashem approve of a gentile's korbon, even that of an idol worshiper? Rav Sorotzkin first restates an idea mentioned earlier, that this non-Jew is exhibiting faith in Hashem as the Supreme Ruler, despite his general worship of idols. If so, why not commend the sacrifice of an idolatrous Jew as well? The Oznaim L'Torah quotes the famous words of the Rama, Rav Moshe Isserles, in Shulchan Aruch Orach Chaim 156:1. "They (the gentiles) are not warned against shituf (pairing up idols with their worship of Hashem)". In other words, it seems from this Rama that the prohibition of idolatry for a non-Jew is if he EXCHANGES G-d for graven images. If he merely JOINS paganistic rites with his service of the Creator, he is not necessarily violating the commandments incumbent on him. This halacha is hotly debated (see Aruch Hashulchan who says it relates only to oaths of shituf, also see numerous sources brought in Shailos Uteshuvos V'shav Hakohen section 38), but this is what the Rama himself states, based on an earlier source. With this in mind, our matter becomes magnificently clear. A non-Jew, a ben Noach, is permitted to practice shituf according to this Rama. True, he is making a grave error in believing that idols have any power at all. But he still feels that Hashem is to be exalted and worshipped. Consequently, his korbon is accepted. On the other hand, it is well-known that a Jew is strictly forbidden to practice any form of idolatry, including shituf, a combined worship of Hashem and another god. Thus, the korbon of such a Jew is rejected.
Now you will understand better my question. It would seem A Xtian can still be keeper of the 7 mitzvot of the Noachide law and is not necessarily avodah zarah.
So am I reading this right?
Did you used to post here as Bandaneira?
Yes.
Sounds like some sort of tropical rum a pirate might once have drunk, non ?
"Traditional Christianity turns the 'Law' on its head and makes obedience to G-d's loving instructions to be something bad, and the rejection of His instructions to be something good."
Can we say, for the sake of discussion, that there are two entities descended from Judaism: Christianity and Christendom. Let us define Christendom as that group often referred to as "Traditional Christianity" making Christianity the group who follow the Way, as in, "I am the Way the Truth and the Life; no man comes to the Father but by me."
In Isaiah 62:11 it is written: Behold, the LORD hath proclaimed Unto the end of the earth: Say ye to the daughter of Zion: "Behold, thy salvation cometh; Behold, His reward is with Him." What is the Hebrew word translated salvation? Do the pronouns His and Him refer back to the salvation which cometh? Why do you think that Christianity does not believe this verse?
Yeshua haMashiach was asked: "What is the great commandment?" He answered: "You shall love the LORD your God with all your heart, and with all your soul, and with all your mind. This is the great and foremost commandment. The second is like it, "You shall love your neighbor as yourself. On these two commandments depend the whole Law and the Prophets." As the Law was important to Him, so it is important to those who follow Him. So, though Christendom may "turn the Law on its head" Christianity seeks to know the Law as it appears in the Tanakh. We wish to know the words of the prophets, so that we may know the will of HaShem.
When I ask questions, no matter how impertinent they seem, it is to make all of us think. Only by keeping the Word in our minds and our hearts can we ever hope to know what the Creator and Father of us all would that we do to glorify Him. I am a believer who follows the Way. And I believe that the Sabbath begins as the sun sets on Friday evening and the First day begins at the same hour on Saturday. Neither of us should look down upon the other for keeping or not keeping either day.
May He who neither slumbers nor sleeps hold you in the palm of His hand. May you one day wake to see Him face to face.
Thanks for the reply.
A good book on this subject, which I refer to often, is...
"The Mitzvot - The Commandments and their Rationale"
by Abraham Chill.
(Keter Publishing House - Urim Publications, Jerusalem.)
He answered: "You shall love the LORD your God with all your heart.."
IMO, you left out the MOST important part he stated.. that is, "Hear O Isreal, the Lord is one" That concept is the very center teaching of all of the scriptures, and the rest of the statement is empty without it.
"the Sadducee sect became extinct after the Roman destruction of Judea"
True. But did the Pharisees recognize them as fellow Jews at the time? They had sharp disagreement, but I've never read that one was rejected by the other as being Jewish.
I wouldn't go that far. I'd say the difference between Karaites and the rest of Jews is about that between Catholics and the various Protestant churches. A significantly different take on Judaism, but still Jewish.
LOL!
Show me where He said that and I will agree that I left it out by accident. But as He did not say that in the passage referred to, the omission was correct and deliberate.
The Karaites split off from the main faith of Judaism just as Christianity did. They are not any more Jewish than Seventh Day Adventists.
1. Do you consider Conservative/Masorti and Reform/Liberal Rabbinates to be Jewish?
2. Wouldn't the Samaritans/Shomronim, who are clearly not Jewish, be a better example? They broke with Judaism, as opposed to Christian sects, that broke from other Christian sects.
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.